Andhra High Court Against Capital Shift?

[Somedude]

1 minute ago, kidney said:

Yeh Govt pay cheyadhu kaka... Polavaram land acquisition to many other land acquisition kae inka money ivaaleru... Capital land acquisition ki istharu anukuntama...

Polavaram ki already kontha pay chesaru, I guess 6 or 8K crores. And aa money theesukunna farmers still farming. Govt eppudu land vadhiley ante appudu vallu complete ga ivvali. Migilina lands ki Polavaram completion time ki pay cheyyali. Aa lands ni farmers still  using. Govt pay cheyadhu anedhi boothu after land acquisition bill (passed by UPA2 Govt).

And that's second defence for Amaravati farmers. CRDA act is the first one. Farmers didn't come into agreement directly with Govt. Its with CRDA. Look into the complete agreement. They don't need to worry about financial loss.

[Spartan]

Special counsel representing the police, S.S Prasad, informed the division bench of AP High Court that it was the prerogative of the state government to decide the location for setting up its capital city on administrative grounds and ruled out any role for the judiciary to intervene.

Arguing before the division bench, comprising Justice Rakesh Kumar and Justice J. Uma Devi, the special counsel asserted that it was the responsibility of the state government to decide which was good and bad keeping in mind the interests of the people and made it clear that there was no role for the judiciary in such issues. He also said that such decisions were not even in the domain of the judiciary.

Moreover, he said, as the issue of setting up three capitals was before the three-member division bench, it was inappropriate to argue on the issue in the court.  He also suggested to the court not to make any statements on the capitals issue.

Referring to Justice Rakesh Kumar, the special counsel said that as the judge came here from other state, he might not be knowing the problems pertaining to the location of the High Court and pointed out they were facing a series of problems like lack of water, less availability of tea or food as the court was located in a far-off place. He asked about the need for setting up the court in such a location with no proper amenities.

Referring to the PILs filed in the HC, he opined that they were not having any public interest except to serve political motives.

Prasad slammed former chief minister N. Chandrababu Naidu for his capricious attitude towards the police by seeking their help when he wanted and finding fault with them when he was in no need of their help. He said that as Naidu arrived in Visakhapatnam to play politics, the police asked him to go back wondering why his party leaders were making a hue and cry on the issue. He opined that Naidu should have filed the PIL if he was so concerned instead of allowing his party leaders to file. He said that the PIL lacked any sanctity for being heard in the court.

He also asked as to how far it could be justified to hold the Chief Minister and DGP responsible when a constable had committed a mistake.

As the petitioner’s counsel S. Pranathi sought time to file a reply to the counter-affidavit filed by the police, the court adjourned the hearing to Monday.

[Ryzen_renoir]

5 minutes ago, Somedude said:

Polavaram ki already kontha pay chesaru, I guess 6 or 8K crores. And aa money theesukunna farmers still farming. Govt eppudu land vadhiley ante appudu vallu complete ga ivvali. Migilina lands ki Polavaram completion time ki pay cheyyali. Aa lands ni farmers still  using. Govt pay cheyadhu anedhi boothu after land acquisition bill (passed by UPA2 Govt).

And that's second defence for Amaravati farmers. CRDA act is the first one. Farmers didn't come into agreement directly with Govt. Its with CRDA. Look into the complete agreement. They don't need to worry about financial loss.

Neeku india lo courts elaga work chetayo theliyadhu rajaa , ippudu unna paristhidhi lo BJP can have any judgement in SC their way . High court emi ichina , ball is in modi-shah court .  Vallu TDP  interests ni favour ga isthara ? 

1.5 lak crores anta , worst case lands return ivvamantaru . State government emi bokka ledhu , malli farms chesi isthundhi . 500 acres lo 2014 rates tho compensation istharu 

[Somedude]

16 minutes ago, Vaampire said:

Amaravathi will still be one of the capitals kada. Appudu break chesinattu avuthunda crda agreement?

The dictionary meaning of capital is seat of governance. Secretariat ni Vizag theesukelthe, Amaravati can't be called as capital. YSRCP Govt 3 capitals ani paper meedha chepthe real meaning chage kaadhu. And farmers didn't sign for that.  CRDA has promises about 9 cities and infrastructure including assembly, secretariat, high court and etc. Court may ask the govt to first finish those things as promised in the CRDA and then move.

[Somedude]

6 minutes ago, Ryzen_renoir said:

Neeku india lo courts elaga work chetayo theliyadhu rajaa , ippudu unna paristhidhi lo BJP can have any judgement in SC their way . High court emi ichina , ball is in modi-shah court .  Vallu TDP  interests ni favour ga isthara ? 

1.5 lak crores anta , worst case lands return ivvamantaru . State government emi bokka ledhu , malli farms chesi isthundhi . 500 acres lo 2014 rates tho compensation istharu 

Mucchatesthundhi nee statements choosthunte. Return discussiosn kooda ayipoyayi. Go read the CRDA agreement fully. Inka nuvve cheppe court working under Mosha, I don't think Mosha will take that risk in Amaravati issue. They may manage in certain issues which favors them.

[Vaampire]

1 minute ago, Somedude said:

The dictionary meaning of capital is seat of governance. Secretariat ni Vizag theesukelthe, Amaravati can't be called as capital. YSRCP Govt 3 capitals ani paper meedha chepthe real meaning chage kaadhu. And farmers didn't sign for that.  CRDA has promises about 9 cities and infrastructure including assembly, secretariat, high court and etc. Court may ask the govt to first finish those things as promised in the CRDA and then move.

Vere states lo kooda Secretariat non capital area undi Ani ee db lo evaro post chesaru.

Capital loney Secretariat/HC/assembly undali ani rule unda? Naaku teliyaka aduguthunna. 

[kidney]

8 hours ago, Spartan said:

Special counsel representing the police, S.S Prasad, informed the division bench of AP High Court that it was the prerogative of the state government to decide the location for setting up its capital city on administrative grounds and ruled out any role for the judiciary to intervene.

Arguing before the division bench, comprising Justice Rakesh Kumar and Justice J. Uma Devi, the special counsel asserted that it was the responsibility of the state government to decide which was good and bad keeping in mind the interests of the people and made it clear that there was no role for the judiciary in such issues. He also said that such decisions were not even in the domain of the judiciary.

Moreover, he said, as the issue of setting up three capitals was before the three-member division bench, it was inappropriate to argue on the issue in the court.  He also suggested to the court not to make any statements on the capitals issue.

Referring to Justice Rakesh Kumar, the special counsel said that as the judge came here from other state, he might not be knowing the problems pertaining to the location of the High Court and pointed out they were facing a series of problems like lack of water, less availability of tea or food as the court was located in a far-off place. He asked about the need for setting up the court in such a location with no proper amenities.

Referring to the PILs filed in the HC, he opined that they were not having any public interest except to serve political motives.

Prasad slammed former chief minister N. Chandrababu Naidu for his capricious attitude towards the police by seeking their help when he wanted and finding fault with them when he was in no need of their help. He said that as Naidu arrived in Visakhapatnam to play politics, the police asked him to go back wondering why his party leaders were making a hue and cry on the issue. He opined that Naidu should have filed the PIL if he was so concerned instead of allowing his party leaders to file. He said that the PIL lacked any sanctity for being heard in the court.

He also asked as to how far it could be justified to hold the Chief Minister and DGP responsible when a constable had committed a mistake.

As the petitioner’s counsel S. Pranathi sought time to file a reply to the counter-affidavit filed by the police, the court adjourned the hearing to Monday.

Haha Prasad evaro kaani aa FC Phulka Chefs ni baga mingadu 

[Somedude]

5 minutes ago, Vaampire said:

Vere states lo kooda Secretariat non capital area undi Ani ee db lo evaro post chesaru.

Capital loney Secretariat/HC/assembly undali ani rule unda? Naaku teliyaka aduguthunna. 

Vere states lo HC different places lo unnayi. Those cities are not called capitals. The place where the governance takes place is called capital. Only J&K has two capitals. But they move everything including secretariat when the chage of capital happens. Irrespective of capital definition, CRDA promises that the HC, Assembly and Secretariat will be located in Amaravati.

[kidney]

7 minutes ago, Somedude said:

The dictionary meaning of capital is seat of governance. Secretariat ni Vizag theesukelthe, Amaravati can't be called as capital. YSRCP Govt 3 capitals ani paper meedha chepthe real meaning chage kaadhu. And farmers didn't sign for that.  CRDA has promises about 9 cities and infrastructure including assembly, secretariat, high court and etc. Court may ask the govt to first finish those things as promised in the CRDA and then move.

Cities(Plots) kadthanu.. Secretariat, HC move chesthanu.. As per agreement Amaravathi still stay as Legislative Capital antae.. Agreement em chesthadhi Kaka

Do you think.. Govt cannot amend agreements Saying for Administration Purpose.. 

[Somedude]

2 minutes ago, kidney said:

Cities(Plots) kadthanu.. Secretariat, HC move chesthanu.. As per agreement Amaravathi still stay as Legislative Capital antae.. Agreement em chesthadhi Kaka

Do you think.. Govt cannot amend agreements Saying for Administration Purpose.. 

Read my earier comment about those.

[kamandalamjalam1]

8 hours ago, ticket said:

Problem ni gajji tho vachindi

kaakaaa....ila nooru veesokoni padithe janaalu bhayapadee roozulu Eenadu destruction thoone aipooyinaayi.

ippudu rickshaw pullers ki kooda ardham aipothunnadhi, how TDP created an unholy nexus among:

Media+PowerPolitics+RealEstate+Judiciary+Police+BankLoans+CastePolarization

Irrespective of how bad CBN is, every Pulka has to keep his photo in their bed rooms and pray him. The way the things are coming out into media, its very clear how for 40 years CBN safeguarded the above unholy nexus and benefitted the whole community.

 

[Ryzen_renoir]

1 minute ago, kamandalamjalam1 said:

kaakaaa....ila nooru veesokoni padithe janaalu bhayapadee roozulu Eenadu destruction thoone aipooyinaayi.

ippudu rickshaw pullers ki kooda ardham aipothunnadhi, how TDP created an unholy nexus among:

Media+PowerPolitics+RealEstate+Judiciary+Police+BankLoans+CastePolarization

Irrespective of how bad CBN is, every Pulka has to keep his photo in their bed rooms and pray him. The way the things are coming out into media, its very clear how for 40 years CBN safeguarded the above unholy nexus and benefitted the whole community.

 

Whole community emi undhi gani , a few percentage has benefited .

Okkapudu Brahmins kooda  tamil nadu (congress party) motham iron grip tho nadipincharu , annadurai ended that 

[kamandalamjalam1]

27 minutes ago, Ryzen_renoir said:

Whole community emi undhi gani , a few percentage has benefited .

Okkapudu Brahmins kooda  tamil nadu (congress party) motham iron grip tho nadipincharu , annadurai ended that 

Thats true in most other cases, but in this case, at least 30-40% directly benefitted. Imagine a loan taken by Srujana Chowdhary for 8000 Crores, most of it will be spent on ventures/projects that directly benefit one community. It will go down the stream into the very common Pulaks in the soceity.

JP Narayan himself told this, around 800 civil servants/clerks/officers wholly took over new Secretariat in Amaravathi and thousands of crores spent on projects that Society never needed, directly benefitting Pulkas.

Imagine 5 Crore per hour billing awarded to ABN-AJ without bidding. A caterer whom I know was paid Rs.5 crore for an year for supplying samosas and mineral water to AP Assembly only. On top of that, there is one more big contract that involves supplying snacks, toilettories, special lunch, special dinner, breakfasts etc....You can imagine the monies involved.

 

 

 

[Hydrockers]

9 hours ago, Somedude said:

Polavaram ki already kontha pay chesaru, I guess 6 or 8K crores. And aa money theesukunna farmers still farming. Govt eppudu land vadhiley ante appudu vallu complete ga ivvali. Migilina lands ki Polavaram completion time ki pay cheyyali. Aa lands ni farmers still  using. Govt pay cheyadhu anedhi boothu after land acquisition bill (passed by UPA2 Govt).

And that's second defence for Amaravati farmers. CRDA act is the first one. Farmers didn't come into agreement directly with Govt. Its with CRDA. Look into the complete agreement. They don't need to worry about financial loss.

Aa agreement copy unte kasta post Vesey bro

 

[Somedude]

47 minutes ago, Hydrockers said:

Aa agreement copy unte kasta post Vesey bro

 

Google. AP Govt website lo untadhi.