Thomas quits as CVC; Supreme Court says appointment was illegal

[Cheddi Chinnodu]

The Supreme Court has ruled that PJ Thomas' appointment as Central Vigilance Commissioner (CVC) is illegal. After the verdict was delivered, Mr Thomas resigned as the country's top man in charge of fighting corruption.  "I respect the Supreme Court's judgement," said the Prime Minister to NDTV.  He said he will make a statement in Parliament on the controversy.

The PM is now in the direct line of fire of the Opposition since he headed the committee that chose Mr Thomas.

Mr Thomas was selected in September by the Prime Minister and Home Minister.  The third member of their committee, Leader of the Opposition, Sushma Swaraj, had objected strongly because Mr Thomas is accused of corruption himself in a criminal case that goes back to the early 90s, when he was a senior bureaucrat in Kerala.

Like Ms Swaraj, the Supreme Court has stressed during the trial that Mr Thomas cannot be in charge of fighting corruption as the Central Vigilance Commissioner when his own integrity is being questioned.  Today, in its judgement, the court said, "The touchstone for the appointment of the CVC is the institutional integrity as well as the personal integrity of the candidate."


The government, in its defense, had argued in court that the biodata for Mr Thomas considered by the PM did not refer to the corruption charges against him. The Supreme Court has rejected that stand, stating that the committee headed by the PM should have "gone beyond the documents" presented to it.

The court also said that the government was incorrect in suggesting that because the post of Chief Vigilance Commissioner is a constitutional one, the Supreme Court is not entitled to review the appointment.  The court said that "the legality of the recommendation can be brought under judicial review."

Ms Swaraj, who has voiced her opposition to Mr Thomas' appointment at different public forums, tweeted after the verdict this morning, "The dignity of the office of CVC has been restored." The Left and the BJP now also want a debate in Parliament on why the government insisted on Mr Thomas as its choice.

As Food Secretary in Kerala in the early 90s, Mr Thomas campaigned aggressively for the import of edible oil from Malaysia. It later emerged that the price paid for the oil - palmolein - was unjustifiably high.  He has since been charged with corruption and conspiracy.

Those charges are the reason why his appointment has been challenged in the Supreme Court by different Public Interest Litigation cases.

Mr Thomas had repeatedly told the court that the fact that he was promoted over the last few years by the Vigilance Commission proves that the charges against him are incorrect and should not affect his career.   

His unceremonious exit comes at a time when the government has been bruised black and blue by a flood of corruption scandals. Leading that list is the 2G spectrum scam which pushed A Raja from the Telecom Minister's office into jail. Mr Raja stands accused of abusing his position and manipulating government policies to award licences for mobile networks at throwaway prices to companies that rewarded him privately with huge kickbacks.

[color=red]Mr Thomas was Telecom Secretary till he was made Central Vigilance Commissioner. The Supreme Court, which is also monitoring the CBI's investigation into the spectrum scam, suggested that it would be inappropriate for Mr Thomas to preside over an inquiry that could subject his own actions in the Telecom Ministry to scrutiny. Mr Thomas then recused himself from the 2G investigation.
[/color]

[katharnak]

@3$% @3$% @3$% @3$% *=:

[ManUtd]

^^" ^^" ^^" *=: *=:

[Alfred pichikaaki]

It happens only in India... ~"! ~"! ~"! ~"! @3$% @3$%

[srdh21]

one more slap on a person with fake honesty and integrity (Mannu)  LoL.1q LoL.1q
kick in the butt of the shameless Italian mafia proxy queen (Sannu)  @3$% @3$%

i dont know what it takes more for this stupid PM to justify his resignation

if PM cannot appoint a right person in the highest constitutional body, it has been quashed by SC

SC is ruling this country and there will not be any worth in his decisions from now, even though he wants to stick to his chair.. shameless moron

chaduvukunna vadikante sakalodu melannaru.. idi nijame  @3$% @3$%

[srdh21]

[quote author=Cheddi Chinnodu link=topic=162683.msg1948168#msg1948168 date=1299169682]
The Supreme Court has ruled that PJ Thomas' appointment as Central Vigilance Commissioner (CVC) is illegal. After the verdict was delivered, Mr Thomas resigned as the country's top man in charge of fighting corruption.  "I respect the Supreme Court's judgement," said the Prime Minister to NDTV.  He said he will make a statement in Parliament on the controversy.

The PM is now in the direct line of fire of the Opposition since he headed the committee that chose Mr Thomas.

Mr Thomas was selected in September by the Prime Minister and Home Minister.  The third member of their committee, Leader of the Opposition, Sushma Swaraj, had objected strongly because Mr Thomas is accused of corruption himself in a criminal case that goes back to the early 90s, when he was a senior bureaucrat in Kerala.

Like Ms Swaraj, the Supreme Court has stressed during the trial that Mr Thomas cannot be in charge of fighting corruption as the Central Vigilance Commissioner when his own integrity is being questioned.  Today, in its judgement, the court said, "The touchstone for the appointment of the CVC is the institutional integrity as well as the personal integrity of the candidate."


The government, in its defense, had argued in court that the biodata for Mr Thomas considered by the PM did not refer to the corruption charges against him. The Supreme Court has rejected that stand, stating that the committee headed by the PM should have "gone beyond the documents" presented to it.

The court also said that the government was incorrect in suggesting that because the post of Chief Vigilance Commissioner is a constitutional one, the Supreme Court is not entitled to review the appointment.  The court said that "the legality of the recommendation can be brought under judicial review."

Ms Swaraj, who has voiced her opposition to Mr Thomas' appointment at different public forums, tweeted after the verdict this morning, "The dignity of the office of CVC has been restored." The Left and the BJP now also want a debate in Parliament on why the government insisted on Mr Thomas as its choice.

As Food Secretary in Kerala in the early 90s, Mr Thomas campaigned aggressively for the import of edible oil from Malaysia. It later emerged that the price paid for the oil - palmolein - was unjustifiably high.  He has since been charged with corruption and conspiracy.

Those charges are the reason why his appointment has been challenged in the Supreme Court by different Public Interest Litigation cases.

Mr Thomas had repeatedly told the court that the fact that he was promoted over the last few years by the Vigilance Commission proves that the charges against him are incorrect and should not affect his career.   

His unceremonious exit comes at a time when the government has been bruised black and blue by a flood of corruption scandals. Leading that list is the 2G spectrum scam which pushed A Raja from the Telecom Minister's office into jail. Mr Raja stands accused of abusing his position and manipulating government policies to award licences for mobile networks at throwaway prices to companies that rewarded him privately with huge kickbacks.

[color=red]Mr Thomas was Telecom Secretary till he was made Central Vigilance Commissioner. The Supreme Court, which is also monitoring the CBI's investigation into the spectrum scam, suggested that it would be inappropriate for Mr Thomas to preside over an inquiry that could subject his own actions in the Telecom Ministry to scrutiny. Mr Thomas then recused himself from the 2G investigation.
[/color]
[/quote]

now Deve Gowda seems to me like a god.. at least he was busy sleeping while honest officials  were honestly running  the govt when is asleep.. Mannu will be remembered as a biggest fraudster india  has ever seen

[keko__keka]

[quote author=srdh21 link=topic=162683.msg1948198#msg1948198 date=1299169973]


chaduvukunna vadikante sakalodu melannaru.. idi nijame  @3$% @3$%
[/quote]

@3$% @3$% @3$%  @gr33d @gr33d @gr33d @gr33d