Calling Benzbabu Doubt About Hindutva And Sanathana Dharma

[charygaru]

please explain what are those and how are they different from one another

[ROUDRAM]

If i am not wrong
we were the followers of Sanatana dhrama.. this was the philosophy that defined our religion
Later days we were called Hindus and the philosophy we followed was called hindutva

kaani manki Hindus ane peru enduku vachindi Idea ledu,, may be from river Indus ( not sure)

[kidmakers]

baa.. Dharma doesnt relate to any god or religion or religious practice. It is just the way a human must act or perform during each situation and phase of his life and to make a note here, Dharma differs from one varna to another varna (varnas are explained in manusmruthi) . But hindutva is all about praying gods, what a person should do in order to be considered as a Hindu and those who follow the religious principles in hindutva are considered hindus and they are sub - divided into various classes.

[kidmakers]

btw sanathana means existing from a long time ani anukuntaa..

[ROUDRAM]

[quote name='kidmakers' timestamp='1320729631' post='3073868']
baa.. Dharma doesnt relate to any god or religion or religious practice. It is just the way a human must act or perform during each situation and phase of his life and to make a note here, Dharma differs from one varna to another varna (varnas are explained in manusmruthi) . But hindutva is all about praying gods, what a person should do in order to be considered as a Hindu and those who follow the religious principles in hindutva are considered hindus and they are sub - divided into various classes.
[/quote]


but isnt it true that sanatana dharma was the found stone for Hinduism. I mean did'nt Hinduism take it roots from Sanatana dhrama

[tom bhayya]

[img]http://www.desigifs.com/sites/default/files/sunil1.gif?1290056327[/img]

[kidmakers]

[quote name='ROUDRAM' timestamp='1320729754' post='3073872']


but isnt it true that sanatana dharma was the found stone for Hinduism
[/quote]


yeah.. most of the principles in hinduism are derived from the practices that are said in the sanathana dharmas.. and the person who practices dharma all through his life without any violation is considered as a god. Hence Rama is considered atop all other gods.

[charygaru]

[quote name='ROUDRAM' timestamp='1320729754' post='3073872']


but isnt it true that sanatana dharma was the found stone for Hinduism. I mean did'nt Hinduism take it roots from Sanatana dhrama
[/quote]

naaku kuda ide telsu

[charygaru]

[quote name='kidmakers' timestamp='1320729631' post='3073868']
baa.. Dharma doesnt relate to any god or religion or religious practice.[size=5][b] It is just the way a human must act or perform during each situation and phase of his life and to make a note here[/b][/size], Dharma differs from one varna to another varna (varnas are explained in manusmruthi) . But hindutva is all about praying gods, what a person should do in order to be considered as a Hindu and those who follow the religious principles in hindutva are considered hindus and they are sub - divided into various classes.
[/quote]

idi evadu raasadu ekkada raasadu who created those set of rules

[kidmakers]

[quote name='charygaru' timestamp='1320730054' post='3073889']

naaku kuda ide telsu
[/quote]


ya.. correct baa.. not only hinduism, most of the religions have their deepest principles derived from sanathana dharma preachings.. muslims sharing their food with poor people during ramzan is one point i guess..

[ROUDRAM]

[quote name='charygaru' timestamp='1320730213' post='3073898']

idi evadu raasadu ekkada raasadu who created those set of rules
[/quote]

agreed naaku kuda doubt... enduku ante

Jaswanth singh rasina Jinah: partion of India book lo cheptadu

Hinduism is a philosophy which was derived from the the existing practices of the people where as islam has defined a set of rule abt how people should live

[kidmakers]

[quote name='charygaru' timestamp='1320730213' post='3073898']

idi evadu raasadu ekkada raasadu who created those set of rules
[/quote]


as per my knowledge (from what i read) this was written after writing the vedas and before the starting of ThreTha yuga (rama's period). Written by Vasishta and some other sages to define how an ideal man should be. And then to show that idealism, Shri Vishnu took the form of Rama and the world understood it. No one ever tried to be an ideal person except dharma raju who lied only once in his life .

[charygaru]

[quote name='kidmakers' timestamp='1320729631' post='3073868']
baa.. Dharma doesnt relate to any god or religion or religious practice. It is just the way a human must act or perform during each situation and phase of his life and to make a note here, [b][size=5]Dharma differs from one varna to another varna (varnas are explained in manusmruthi)[/size][/b] . But hindutva is all about praying gods, what a person should do in order to be considered as a Hindu and those who follow the religious principles in hindutva are considered hindus and they are sub - divided into various classes.
[/quote]

malla ee classification endi vayya kshatriya , brahamna , sudra vaishya are the four varnas kada?

arent those a part of our culture or am i confusin it with something else o.O

[kidmakers]

[quote name='ROUDRAM' timestamp='1320730389' post='3073905']

agreed naaku kuda doubt... enduku ante

Jaswanth singh rasina Jinah: partion of India book lo cheptadu

Hinduism is a philosophy which was derived from the the existing practices of the people where as islam has defined a set of rule abt how people should live
[/quote]


yeah.. he is partially right.. i dont agree much with the second point though.. what islam said is the same all religions would do. even Budhdha also made a set of rules and those who follow his principles are considered Budhdhists right.. ??

[ROUDRAM]

[quote name='kidmakers' timestamp='1320730393' post='3073906']


as per my knowledge (from what i read) this was written after writing the vedas and before the starting of ThreTha yuga (rama's period). [b]Written by Vasishta and some other sages to define how an ideal man should be[/b]. And then to show that idealism, Shri Vishnu took the form of Rama and the world understood it. No one ever tried to be an ideal person except dharma raju who lied only once in his life .
[/quote]


hmmm... idi koncham thinkalsinde .. I heard an entirely different version