Is Gst Bill Worse Than Land Bill?

[lazybugger]

The GST bill that was passed yesterday in the Lok Sabha was beyond horrendous.

 

Do they really expect TamilNadu to support this bill? lol.

 

the thing about GST is, it tries to give an answer to a question that no wants answered.

 

The question is: Should India be a unified market?

 

 

[siru]

Gst enti?

[lazybugger]

Gst enti?

 

sales tax, service tax, excise tax, central sales tax ani inka konni taxes antha kalipi, GST ani pedthaam ani proposal.

 

anduvalla taxes easy avuthaayi anta. especially interstate goods movement easy ayyi, India antha oka market avuthundi anta..

 

veellantha business chesina mokhaale na.

 

prasthutham emo, anni states have their own tax slabs for different materials. 

[lbs]

sales tax, service tax, excise tax, central sales tax ani inka konni taxes antha kalipi, GST ani pedthaam ani proposal.

anduvalla taxes easy avuthaayi anta. especially interstate goods movement easy ayyi, India antha oka market avuthundi anta..

veellantha business chesina mokhaale na.

prasthutham emo, anni states have their own tax slabs for different materials.

[dalapathi]

sales tax, service tax, excise tax, central sales tax ani inka konni taxes antha kalipi, GST ani pedthaam ani proposal.

 

anduvalla taxes easy avuthaayi anta. especially interstate goods movement easy ayyi, India antha oka market avuthundi anta..

 

veellantha business chesina mokhaale na.

 

prasthutham emo, anni states have their own tax slabs for different materials. 

but liquor, petrol, diesel, cigarettes vaatiki maatram states extra tax vesukovachu annaru. TN ki yearly  15k-20k crores ooh emo revenue vastadi kada liquor meeda. main source of income ki loss lenappudu inekmi problem?

[srikanthraparla]

[Cool]

Why is land bill worst in the first place?

[athletics]

sales tax, service tax, excise tax, central sales tax ani inka konni taxes antha kalipi, GST ani pedthaam ani proposal.

anduvalla taxes easy avuthaayi anta. especially interstate goods movement easy ayyi, India antha oka market avuthundi anta..

veellantha business chesina mokhaale na.

prasthutham emo, anni states have their own tax slabs for different materials.

Good for consumers bad for state governments esp down south, to my shock I ended up paying 36% taxes at a upscale restaurant in Hyderabad because of the loop holes in the taxation and got mad how these people were exploiting. Anyways for the first 5 years government owed state governments to fulfil the deficit

[lazybugger]

but liquor, petrol, diesel, cigarettes vaatiki maatram states extra tax vesukovachu annaru. TN ki yearly  15k-20k crores ooh emo revenue vastadi kada liquor meeda. main source of income ki loss lenappudu inekmi problem?

 

yeah, liquor main revenue for TN.

 

but loss undhi. manufacturing lower cost places ki transfer aythundi, because the rates are uniform, and input credit will be provided irrespective of where the product was manufactured.

 

plus. states can have extra 1% on interstate goods ani undi. This means that the new central sales tax will be 1% instead of 4%, but the problem is not with the rate itself.

 

The problem is with the implementation. All the goods transported out of state, will still have to spend days at the border to enter another state.

 

So what exactly is GST achieving? Its a loss: loss for both states and traders. especially slightly industrialized states like Maharashtra and Tamilnadu.

[siru]

sales tax, service tax, excise tax, central sales tax ani inka konni taxes antha kalipi, GST ani pedthaam ani proposal.

anduvalla taxes easy avuthaayi anta. especially interstate goods movement easy ayyi, India antha oka market avuthundi anta..

veellantha business chesina mokhaale na.

prasthutham emo, anni states have their own tax slabs for different materials.

Tatha... Pottip mana BJp ni maree mukhyam ga modi ni indirect ga 10gadu
Em cheddam pottip ni?
Kindly let me know

[lazybugger]

 

tax katte business gurinchi cheppa le ba.

[lazybugger]

Good for consumers bad for state governments esp down south, to my shock I ended up paying 36% taxes at a upscale restaurant in Hyderabad because of the loop holes in the taxation and got mad how these people were exploiting. Anyways for the first 5 years government owed state governments to fulfil the deficit

 

I don't understand this at all. everybody keeps saying it, but its impractical.

 

how can anyone predict how much the state has lost?

 

I mean, why should India be a single market place at all? Isn't USA doing well leaving states to take care of the sales taxes.

[athletics]

yeah, liquor main revenue for TN.

but loss undhi. manufacturing lower cost places ki transfer aythundi, because the rates are uniform, and input credit will be provided irrespective of where the product was manufactured.

plus. states can have extra 1% on interstate goods ani undi. This means that the new central sales tax will be 1% instead of 4%, but the problem is not with the rate itself.

The problem is with the implementation. All the goods transported out of state, will still have to spend days at the border to enter another state.

So what exactly is GST achieving? Its a loss: loss for both states and traders. especially slightly industrialized states like Maharashtra and Tamilnadu.

Yes agree on some points. Thought liquor is left out from GST, isn't it?

[lazybugger]

india lo first Income tax penchaali. ee consumption taxes thagginchaali, if they have any concern for the aam admi/aurat.

[Kickuu]

No Way..Its by Far da best Tax Reform ever in India.. Having One Unified Tax System across all over India Boosts Investors Confidence, though it strips off States Authority on Taxes..