Jump to content

Ben Stokes Obstruction Dismissal.....out Or Not Out?


Recommended Posts

Posted

[media]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2BXDRlboPSI[/media]

 

 

ee aussie gallaki bottiga kreeda spurthi ledu  ben stokes gaadiki moham meedha tagulutundi emo ani addu pettadu daanike nana hungama chesaaru aus...smith gaadu aus aggressive ni continue chestunnada   :3D_Smiles_38:  :3D_Smiles_38:

 

 

 

  • Replies 34
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • biscuitRAJA000

    8

  • ronitreddy

    6

  • Yuva Nataratna

    4

  • lazybugger

    4

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

The more you look at the Stokes dismissal, the more out it looks. No way of knowing intent, you have to judge the action, the movement.

 

MCC may have just crossed off one name from their possible list of speakers at next years Spirit of Cricket Cowdrey Lecture!!

 

Turning nasty at Lord's. Never heard booing so loud or sustained @HomeOfCricket. #stokes

 

Jonathan Agnew 

In real time would Stokes really have had time to think about deflecting ball from the stumps? Stand by for bowlers hurling ball at batsmen

 
 

We didn't like to see what happened at Lords, here's a closer look at the law ! Feel for Stokes....

 
 
 

 

 

 

 
 
 
 

 

Posted

 

McCullum slams Steve Smith over Stokes controversy

 

New Zealand captain Brendon McCullum weighed in on the Ben Stokes' controversial 'obstructing the field' dismissal in the second England-Australia One-Day International (ODI) and suggested that Australian captain Steve Smith missed a great opportunity to set a precedent with his handling of the incident.

Stokes became only the seventh cricketer to be given out 'obstructing the field' when he palmed away a Mitchell Starc throw on the follow-through, in an apparent act of self defense. McCullum said that cricket's reputation of being the gentleman's game would have been well served had Smith withdrawn the appeal.

"It's probably too early in Steve Smith's captaincy career to appreciate this but, one day he'll look back at the Ben Stokes dismissal at Lord's on Saturday and realise he missed a great opportunity to strike a blow for the spirit of cricket," McCullum wrote in his column for the Daily Mail.

McCullum said he was speaking from his experience of running out Muttiah Muralitharan while the off-spinner was celebrating his partner Kumar Sangakkara's century. The Kiwi skipper added that he would have handled that incident very differently now.

"We've all done things on the field that we regret later. I know I certainly have. But it was disappointing that Smith had a chance to make a statement about the way he wants his side to play the game and chose to go the other way. Winning is important but the longer you play this game the more you realise that some things are too valuable to spoil. By not withdrawing the appeal, Smith showed his immaturity. He may live to regret it," McCullum opined.

Meanwhile, there was also support for the new Australian captain from Michael Vaughan, who said that Smith was well within the rules to appeal for the dismissal but added that the incident would set an example in an era where teams are willing to push the boundaries in a bid to play an aggressive brand of cricket. "Steven Smith did not do anything wrong in appealing for the dismissal of Ben Stokes but the incident has set a precedent and I would now be telling my bowlers to throw it back at the batsman if they get a chance," Vaughan wrote in his Telegraph column.

"If the ball strikes a hand, glove or bat then it will have to be out. I think we will see it happening more and more, particularly in an era when players are being aggressive and trying to advance down the pitch or throw the ball at a batsman to try and intimidate him. Smith is a young captain desperate to win his first series as well as look tough and hard. A more experienced captain five years into the job would probably have called Stokes back but when you first start you do not want to show any sign of weakness, and after losing the Ashes, Australia want to give England a good hiding in the one-dayers."

 

 

Posted

antha clear ga ball ni pattukunadu kada man..self defense ani Eng vallu antaru..kadu intentionally ani OZ valla feeling..Evaru vallu correct..kani Smith back pilisthe matram OZ gallu pakka odipoye vaaru..This is an important win for aussie

Posted

antha clear ga ball ni pattukunadu kada man..self defense ani Eng vallu antaru..kadu intentionally ani OZ valla feeling..Evaru vallu correct..kani Smith back pilisthe matram OZ gallu pakka odipoye vaaru..This is an important win for aussie

how can you be sure? 
next ball ee out ayyevademo , who knows

kachitam ga ENg vallu gelichevallu ani cheppaleemu. there might be chance photo-52624.jpg?_r=1441388148

Posted

how can you be sure? 
next ball ee out ayyevademo , who knows

kachitam ga ENg vallu gelichevallu ani cheppaleemu. there might be chance photo-52624.jpg?_r=1441388148

ok..!!

Posted

antha clear ga ball ni pattukunadu kada man..self defense ani Eng vallu antaru..kadu intentionally ani OZ valla feeling..Evaru vallu correct..kani Smith back pilisthe matram OZ gallu pakka odipoye vaaru..This is an important win for aussie

replay lo clear gane anipistundi but real time chooste vaadu defence chesukovaddaniki anipistundi ind vs aus match lo david hussey gaadu ilage cheste manollu vadilesaaru  kada...aus gallu mari  valla daggariki vacchesariki not out pakkodi daggariki vacchesariki out aa  :3D_Smiles_38:

 

[media]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q02P6jrZHwI[/media]

Posted

replay lo clear gane anipistundi but real time chooste vaadu defence chesukovaddaniki anipistundi ind vs aus match lo david hussey gaadu ilage cheste manollu vadilesaaru  kada...aus gallu mari  valla daggariki vacchesariki not out pakkodi daggariki vacchesariki out aa  :3D_Smiles_38:

 

[media]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q02P6jrZHwI[/media]

If i remember it correctly, indians appealed..Billy has referred to third umpire kuda..and the decision came against india anukunta..

 

Dhoni had an argument with Billy kuda appudu..Aina lot of factors come into consideration sporting spirit ani just cheppadam kadu..

Posted

If i remember it correctly, indians appealed..Billy has referred to third umpire kuda..and the decision came against india anukunta..

 

Dhoni had an argument with Billy kuda appudu..Aina lot of factors come into consideration sporting spirit ani just cheppadam kadu..

yes man not out iccharu appudu clear ga hussey gaadu  ball ni choosi aapadu ........

Posted

Based on these two videos... if Hussey is not out then Stokes should also not out....

Posted

yes man not out iccharu appudu clear ga hussey gaadu  ball ni choosi aapadu ........

akkada not out ichindi third umpire ee..ikkada ichindi third umpire ee..

 

Asalu 3rd umpire refer chesaka malli back ela pilustharu..

×
×
  • Create New...