Mani Rathnam-Overrated Director

[nastyguys]

[quote author=venky29 link=topic=75463.msg798668#msg798668 date=1276902747]
fantstic movie

[/quote]

naa GIF ki meaning neeku ardam kaledu anukunta ....

[krldr871]

[quote author=Amrutham link=topic=75463.msg797959#msg797959 date=1276885362]
Maniratnam's movies are often direct copy of some part of mahabharatha and other epics. For example:

Roja -- Sathi Savithri story. Wife doing all the hardhips to save hubby.

Dhalapathi -- Story of Karna and Duryodhana.

Raavan - Ramayana (it seems, I din see the movie)

But I think Geethanjali, Nayakudu, Gharshana etc are original.
[/quote]
lol this is the funniest argument i ever heard..
to start with, nothing is absolutely original..ne opinions, ne knowledge, ne thoughts, attitude, characteristics ivanni nuvvu perigina situations ni batti, chuttu unde manushula batti, ne meedha unna influences batti erpadathayi..so originality in the truest sense does not exist..if u think some thing is original, it only means that u r unaware of the source..
RGV, mani ratnam or for that matter any director u talk about, they are all story tellers..oka story lo chaala characters untayi..prati character lo vaalla characteristics or vallu chusina, kalisina, vinna, chadivina manushula gurinchi, different paristitulalo nunchi vachina anubhavala meedha base cheskuni untadi..
roja ane movie sathi savitri story ante, ah influence valla, savitri character nachadam valla, generate ayina thought roja..similar ga RGV sarkar theesadu ante, god father movie influence+bal thackeray ni mumbai lo chusina experience tho alanti character raaskunadu..
so there is nothing truly original..ala ani anni copy ee na ante kaadhu..inspiration, influence different..copy anedhi different..homam ante mushti cinema, JD gadu departed nunchi scene to scene kottadu almost..climax the recruit nunchi dimpaadu..adi kuda oka type of influence ee..kani vadi talent ki daanni replicate cheyagaligadu kani adapt cheyalekapoyadu..
so copy ani, idi original ani judgmental ga opinions base cheskodam correct kadu ani na opinion

[bhrami]

[quote author=krldr871 link=topic=75463.msg798747#msg798747 date=1276904925]
lol this is the funniest argument i ever heard..
to start with, nothing is absolutely original..ne opinions, ne knowledge, ne thoughts, attitude, characteristics ivanni nuvvu perigina situations ni batti, chuttu unde manushula batti, ne meedha unna influences batti erpadathayi..so originality in the truest sense does not exist..if u think some thing is original, it only means that u r unaware of the source..
RGV, mani ratnam or for that matter any director u talk about, they are all story tellers..oka story lo chaala characters untayi..prati character lo vaalla characteristics or vallu chusina, kalisina, vinna, chadivina manushula gurinchi, different paristitulalo nunchi vachina anubhavala meedha base cheskuni untadi..
roja ane movie sathi savitri story ante, ah influence valla, savitri character nachadam valla, generate ayina thought roja..similar ga RGV sarkar theesadu ante, god father movie influence+bal thackeray ni mumbai lo chusina experience tho alanti character raaskunadu..
so there is nothing truly original..ala ani anni copy ee na ante kaadhu..inspiration, influence different..copy anedhi different..homam ante mushti cinema, JD gadu departed nunchi scene to scene kottadu almost..climax the recruit nunchi dimpaadu..adi kuda oka type of influence ee..kani vadi talent ki daanni replicate cheyagaligadu kani adapt cheyalekapoyadu..
so copy ani, idi original ani judgmental ga opinions base cheskodam correct kadu ani na opinion
[/quote]
[img]http://www.bewarsetalk.net/discus/movieanimated7/chevilo.puvvu.gif[/img]

[krldr871]

[quote author=bhrami link=topic=75463.msg798754#msg798754 date=1276905130]
[img]http://www.bewarsetalk.net/discus/movieanimated7/chevilo.puvvu.gif[/img]
[/quote]
Smartness runs in my family. When I went to school I was so smart my teacher was in my class for five years  ~"! ~"!

[bhrami]

[quote author=krldr871 link=topic=75463.msg798792#msg798792 date=1276905718]
Smartness runs in my family. When I went to school I was so smart my teacher was in my class for five years  ~"! ~"!
[/quote]
Yes yes  ~"! ~"! ~"!

[AFDBphilosopher]

[quote author=krldr871 link=topic=75463.msg798747#msg798747 date=1276904925]
lol this is the funniest argument i ever heard..
to start with, nothing is absolutely original..ne opinions, ne knowledge, ne thoughts, attitude, characteristics ivanni nuvvu perigina situations ni batti, chuttu unde manushula batti, ne meedha unna influences batti erpadathayi..so originality in the truest sense does not exist..if u think some thing is original, it only means that u r unaware of the source..
RGV, mani ratnam or for that matter any director u talk about, they are all story tellers..oka story lo chaala characters untayi..prati character lo vaalla characteristics or vallu chusina, kalisina, vinna, chadivina manushula gurinchi, different paristitulalo nunchi vachina anubhavala meedha base cheskuni untadi..
roja ane movie sathi savitri story ante, ah influence valla, savitri character nachadam valla, generate ayina thought roja..similar ga RGV sarkar theesadu ante, god father movie influence+bal thackeray ni mumbai lo chusina experience tho alanti character raaskunadu..
so there is nothing truly original..ala ani anni copy ee na ante kaadhu..inspiration, influence different..copy anedhi different..homam ante mushti cinema, JD gadu departed nunchi scene to scene kottadu almost..climax the recruit nunchi dimpaadu..adi kuda oka type of influence ee..kani vadi talent ki daanni replicate cheyagaligadu kani adapt cheyalekapoyadu..
so copy ani, idi original ani judgmental ga opinions base cheskodam correct kadu ani na opinion
[/quote]

babu, all that i am saying is maniratnam adapted those master pieces and made movies out of them. It is not just influence or inspiration. He consciously adapted it.

Influence is something that happens sub consciously.

[krldr871]

[quote author=Amrutham link=topic=75463.msg798823#msg798823 date=1276906703]
babu, all that i am saying is maniratnam adapted those master pieces and made movies out of them. It is not just influence or inspiration. He consciously adapted it.

Influence is something that happens sub consciously.
[/quote]
influence or inspiration ani nene cheppanu..nuvvu copy annavu..chala diff undi..