Mani ratnam

[VizagRocks]

Maniratnam awesome.

much better RGV. sure.

but some modern Tamil directors are way way ahead of Maniratnam. and some Hindi directors too.

[mettastar]

12 minutes ago, saradagakasepu said:

vantage point movie kuda  alane untadi kada...same scene from every other person's view

vantage point yuva tharvatha vachindhi anukunta kada

[Seshu_]

4 minutes ago, Maryadaramanna said:

yeah, vantage point kuda alaane vuntadi; but copy ni kuda kichidi chese directors vunnaru kada

yaa kichidi chese vallu vunnaru le... maniratnam mana nativity ki peddhaga adapt chesindhi kooda yemi ledhu yuva lo... it looks like a straight copy of screenplay with different stories anthe... ofcourse, big stars and ar rahman is a plus

[VizagRocks]

15 minutes ago, siru said:

yup..shameless ripoff

nothing shameless about it. He just used the narrative technique.

It is much better than what another moron tried to do with Ghajini.

[VizagRocks]

6 minutes ago, Seshu_ said:

yaa kichidi chese vallu vunnaru le... maniratnam mana nativity ki peddhaga adapt chesindhi kooda yemi ledhu yuva lo... it looks like a straight copy of screenplay with different stories anthe... ofcourse, big stars and ar rahman is a plus

nativity antey, only tamil possible for Maniratnam. that too tambrahm only. anavasaranga Hindi try chesi yerri puvvu avthaadu.

ofcourse hindi means more money, so he doesn't mind anuko. choosey janam ae erri puvvus finally.

[Seshu_]

5 minutes ago, VizagRocks said:

Maniratnam awesome.

much better RGV. sure.

but some modern Tamil directors are way way ahead of Maniratnam. and some Hindi directors too.

yevaru vaaru? Can i say karthik subbaraj, selva raghavan and mysskin are few of them?

[VizagRocks]

Maniratnam is not a director in the traditional sense. He's more a man of exquisite taste, and has the ability to identify and attract skillful people around him. Or atleast had.

He will remembered forever for making the most beautiful and pointless films.

[nenesuperni]

i want bombai mani ratnam 

[VizagRocks]

22 minutes ago, Mr47 said:

I believe mani ratnam is the only guy who can deal with so many stars in one movie like yuva, iddaru, amrutha, dalapathi, mounaragam.. You see strong screenplay in his movies not stars 

only dalapathi had 'stars'. otherwise, maniratnam these days seems to make movies out of talking points he picks up from the old age home he lives in.

But then, he deserves to make another 10 bad films, just because he made Iruvar. He'll be excused for ripping off viewers with his outdated movies.

[VizagRocks]

3 minutes ago, nenesuperni said:

i want bombai mani ratnam 

you have to rewatch bombai then.

[Mr47]

But he got his own creativity and he stucked to that, but if you look directors like rajamouli and shankar, they always rely on commercial value. You feel bore if you see rajamouli and shankar movies 

For me mani ratnam,vishal bharadwaj, anurag kashyp, neeraj pandey are good in dealing the subject.

[VizagRocks]

Just now, Mr47 said:

But he got his own creativity and he stucked to that, but if you look directors like rajamouli and shankar, they always rely on commercial value. You feel bore if you see rajamouli and shankar movies 

For me mani ratnam,vishal bharadwaj, anurag kashyp, neeraj pandey are good in dealing the subject.

okay. maniratnam is also a purely commercial director, but he caters to a different section of the audience.

He used to do it well. His Iruvar was an exception. Even he doesn't know how and why he made that movie.

[Mr47]

He don't really force comedy and fights into the movie, unfortunately we just stuck to regular commercial movies..you don't miss art in his movie that why every actor want to be part of his movies 

[VizagRocks]

8 minutes ago, Seshu_ said:

yevaru vaaru? Can i say karthik subbaraj, selva raghavan and mysskin are few of them?

ameer, bala, vetrimaaran, nalan kumarasamy, thyagarajan kumararaja, Ram, inka I don't know. There may be others.

[4Vikram]

1 hour ago, VizagRocks said:

nothing shameless about it. He just used the narrative technique.

It is much better than what another moron tried to do with Ghajini.

dont even compare Memento with Ghazini man, like as you said MR used narrative technique here MD used story line thats it..