Is Aaron Rodgers a better QB than Tom Brady?

[Naaperushiva]

Just now, Ara_Tenkai said:

anthe avg stats unnayi ante team manchiga ledu ani kuda anukovachu kada...

POSt season ki qualified with those stats antey mostly one side of the ball anna baaga vundi vundaali..

 

[Pipucbn]

LOL don’t compare rings... rings are for the team not just for QB.

QB to QB comparison ki you see the passer rating and touch down to interception ratio 

now go check and come and argue

[Naaperushiva]

It's simple bro TB laanti resume pettukuni kooda janaalu and chaala mandhi analysts brady ni and Arod ni compare chesthunnaru antey aalochinchaali..

But first of all ee comparisons ey kastam....Football is a team game..

Offense can win you the championships but only a proper D can win u the S bowl...

Classic example super bowl 50 ....Von gaadu single handed gaa manning thaatha ki icchadu SB 

[Naaperushiva]

Inka comebacks comebacks ane vallaki idhi...DEF ganuka points okaside lo aapakapothe offense enni points score chesina waste...

 

[Ara_Tenkai]

11 minutes ago, Pipucbn said:

LOL don’t compare rings... rings are for the team not just for QB.

QB to QB comparison ki you see the passer rating and touch down to interception ratio 

now go check and come and argue

TD or interceptions ki kuda team kavali bro... just QB throw chesi vade TD pass catch cheyaledu kada... everything depends on the team...

[sattipandu]

why does this discussion come up every yr  in this DB

in 2011 and 2012 it was ELI vs TB

in 2013 and 2014 it was Peyton vs TB

2014-2018 either Big Ben or ROdgers vs TB

The common remainder has been TB12 , he is GOAT and irreplaceable and uncomparable to anyone in this context

I dont care how many theatrically wonderful plays you can make , i amy jump in joy during regular season watching them but come  Playoffs 

PATS and TB12 are strapped on and marching into AFC game, business as usual 

 

excited to see Brees breaking all time passing records this yr , excellent gun slinger faaar faaar better than Brett Favre, too bad Drees doesnt get that much praise as he deserves

 

[Pipucbn]

2 minutes ago, Ara_Tenkai said:

TD or interceptions ki kuda team kavali bro... just QB throw chesi vade TD pass catch cheyaledu kada... everything depends on the team...

Ala anukunte parameters ye unnav for comparison. So in that case why are they even comparing

QB performance is measured on those lines.

same thing for RB you measure the Yards after contact. Yards per touch

 

[InSearch]

@Naaperushiva 

You can compare WRs, DBs, CBs..etc as their assignments are mostly individual

When it comes to QBs, a lot depends on the team work and execution

TB and Peyton Manning can read defenses better than A-ROD and that is why they don't have to do circus plays in every drive

Brees is different in his own style

A-ROD makes amazing throws on the run (many of those defy laws of physics), with great accuracy

In my opinion, he should've sacrificed some money to get good O-Line and win SBs..

It's not Tennis that only A-ROD can make them win all the time and that's why they are stumbling in playoffs

People say TB12 had great coaches and players around him.. 

None of the Pats coaches succeeded after leaving Pats

Most of the players are not succeeded after leaving Pats

BB is a master mind and there are several master minds out there.. they made each other great..

You could say and thank Bill O'Brien and Josh McDaniels who helped TB12 to become what he is..

BB is the Defensive master mind and look what happened in AFC championship and SB.. 

[InSearch]

LTT for discussion 

[sattipandu]

19 minutes ago, InSearch said:

LTT for discussion 

No discussion  if you are picking a qb for fantasy pick rodgers

if you are picking see your team in playoffs and aadvance playoffs pick Brady 

[Pipucbn]

17 minutes ago, sattipandu said:

No discussion  if you are picking a qb for fantasy pick rodgers

if you are picking see your team in playoffs and aadvance playoffs pick Brady 

[InSearch]

1 hour ago, sattipandu said:

No discussion  if you are picking a qb for fantasy pick rodgers

if you are picking see your team in playoffs and aadvance playoffs pick Brady 

vokey... can't wait to see them both playing.. Nov 4th

[chittimallu2]

On 9/10/2018 at 2:20 PM, Naaperushiva said:

So ee case lo sachin tendulkar greatest batsmen antaara ledha.....ricky ponting ni antaaru...

just becoz ricky won more trophies

 

Pure QB based ayithe obvsly it's rodgers..inka resume based ayithe obvsly brady.

 

I dont watch NFL and dont like the sport so only responding to your cricket analogy here..

cricket is a different breed of sport, its not a team sport. NFL is a team sport. You can say cricket has 11 players so its a team game but no, its actually not for the most part... NFL, football and hockey (not the ice one) are the mostly team sports... even basketball isnt as much a team sport as the above three. 

Especially in your analogy, to compare two batsmen's greatness you dont need to weigh in their trophies because a batsman's job is to score runs and scoring in cricket is independent of other 10 players barring an odd runout which holds a minute percentage. 

[DaleSteyn1]

6 minutes ago, chittimallu2 said:

I dont watch NFL and dont like the sport so only responding to your cricket analogy here..

cricket is a different breed of sport, its not a team sport. NFL is a team sport. You can say cricket has 11 players so its a team game but no, its actually not for the most part... NFL, football and hockey (not the ice one) are the mostly team sports... even basketball isnt as much a team sport as the above three. 

Especially in your analogy, to compare two batsmen's greatness you dont need to weigh in their trophies because a batsman's job is to score runs and scoring in cricket is independent of other 10 players barring an odd runout which holds a minute percentage. 

Acha

[Naaperushiva]

1 hour ago, chittimallu2 said:

I dont watch NFL and dont like the sport so only responding to your cricket analogy here..

cricket is a different breed of sport, its not a team sport. NFL is a team sport. You can say cricket has 11 players so its a team game but no, its actually not for the most part... NFL, football and hockey (not the ice one) are the mostly team sports... even basketball isnt as much a team sport as the above three. 

Especially in your analogy, to compare two batsmen's greatness you dont need to weigh in their trophies because a batsman's job is to score runs and scoring in cricket is independent of other 10 players barring an odd runout which holds a minute percentage. 

Seriously bro cricket team game kaadha...Em maatlaaduthunnav kaaka

Agreed NFL and football antha kaadhu...but see oka individual batsman entha kottina bowlers biscuit vesthe dobbinatte gaa and fielding kooda...So u cant simply say that cricket isnt a team game..

So nuvvu cheppina analogy prakaarame cheppina QB's job is to score touch downs and is to secure the ball..

So nenu adey antunna when u r comparing two Qb's compare them based on their stats and skillset...Not based on SB's won etc etc ani