Why Roy was not given out?

[cosmopolitan]

endhuku out ivaledhu, DRS lo clear ga ball hitting stumps kadha .. experts chipin ?

[reality]

1 minute ago, cosmopolitan said:

endhuku out ivaledhu, DRS lo clear ga ball hitting stumps kadha .. experts chipin ?

Umpire’s call stays on impact.

[Katti_Ramdas]

1 minute ago, cosmopolitan said:

endhuku out ivaledhu, DRS lo clear ga ball hitting stumps kadha .. experts chipin ?

Rani garu order anta

[johnydanylee]

Fixed 

[cosmopolitan]

2 minutes ago, reality said:

Umpire’s call stays on impact.

i feel it was not fair.. game motham turn ayedhi.. if Roy was out.

[reality]

2 minutes ago, cosmopolitan said:

i feel it was not fair.. game motham turn ayedhi.. if Roy was out.

Yes, thats the fcuked up part of DRS.

[Somedude]

2 minutes ago, cosmopolitan said:

endhuku out ivaledhu, DRS lo clear ga ball hitting stumps kadha .. experts chipin ?

Same happened with Kohli. they have given it out. Its controversial. I see if the ball is not hitting the middle stump and middle of the stump...umpires mostly go by their own decision what they think of. On field they don't have access to the DRS scan results. This is one thing ICC should come up with formal rule instead of having ambiguous rule.

[cosmopolitan]

1 minute ago, Somedude said:

Same happened with Kohli. they have given it out. Its controversial. I see if the ball is not hitting the middle stump and middle of the stump...umpires mostly go by their own decision what they think of. On field they don't have access to the DRS scan results. This is one thing ICC should come up with formal rule instead of having ambiguous rule.

apudu India povali.. ipudu England gelavali.. alane undhi chusthunte.

[Somedude]

2 minutes ago, cosmopolitan said:

apudu India povali.. ipudu England gelavali.. alane undhi chusthunte.

Yeah...can't blame if different umpire. I think the same happened with another batsman..I guess Nezland..different umpire...it was given not out. blame should go to the ICC. They should have some formal rule about if the ball hits any part of stumps or some % of the stumps in the scans...like that.

[kothavani]

11 minutes ago, cosmopolitan said:

endhuku out ivaledhu, DRS lo clear ga ball hitting stumps kadha .. experts chipin ?

https://m.facebook.com/Cricinfo/videos/10154638133477555/

 

[kothavani]

11 minutes ago, cosmopolitan said:

endhuku out ivaledhu, DRS lo clear ga ball hitting stumps kadha .. experts chipin ?

Basic ga if it pitches outside off , and ball was in impact with stumps only 50 percent, so it’s not fool proof anta a pai video lo chepadu, apudu umpires call anta , in this case new rule lo team will not loose review anta ento mari

[reality]

1 minute ago, reality said:

3 checks red untene out

1. pitched in line - Red

2. ball hitting leg in line - Red

3. projected impact - if original umpire’s call is out plus if ball tracking shows hitting stumps, then red, else yellow (not out)

@cosmopolitan

 

 

[cosmopolitan]

2 minutes ago, kothavani said:

https://m.facebook.com/Cricinfo/videos/10154638133477555/

 

got it.. technology lo, error tolerance anamata.. thanks for the video.. 

[cosmopolitan]

1 minute ago, reality said:

 

thanks @reality

 

[kothavani]

Endo a match chustundte final laga ledu crowd arupulu levu statdium Jam packed ledu enthaina india , Pakistan unte ne kala matches ki