Asal southern states India lo enduku undali

[Android_Halwa]

The arguement of states contributing for center anedi oka invalid arguement.

Just because a state os contributing more , that means that state is earning more and makes sense to make a bit more contribution to aid other states.

Idi emaina HUF leka muslim personal law kadu, evadi vaatalu vaadiki ivadaniki...idi Government, profit and non profit gurinchi chepadaniki provate companiy kadu...welfare chusdalsindi Government.

Southern India la water shortage aye scope chala ekuva vundi, Northern Plains is excess..repati dinam interlinking tho mahanadi-godavari-krishna-kaveri link chesthe, mari arou kuda ie arguement chesthara ? 

No state can live completely on their own...there is not even one state which can sustain completely on its own with its own resources, for most goods and services, inter state trade is very important and as long as all these exist, arguements like I am contributing more to taxes ane vaadana bekaar muchata...

[Android_Halwa]

Western, Northern and Eastern boundries need heavy spending on security...mari veetiki evadu iyali ?

Southern coastal borders la Navy vuntadi...but northies pay chese tax army ki vadukovali kani Navy ki use cheyochu kada...similarly Southies should not pay for border security and just secure the waters..

mari idi etla solve cheyali ?

[batman2]

3 hours ago, veeraveeraleaks said:

Patriotism part pakkana pedithe................

 

1. Asal manaki higher posts ranivvaru. (After PV and deve gowda. I dont remember there was any) 

2. national parties all are north-based ( BJP, congress etc)

3. Anni budgets lo southern states ki hand istharu ( Yearly, railways etc)

4. Revenue icchedhi maname  ( TG, AP, TN and KA). Love da lo Bihar, MP, UP, rajasthan lu peekedhi em ledhu akkada

eeeee love da lo North gallu chesedhi em ledhuuuuu. dadagiri thappa due to high population and more representation in parliament. 

4. how much does north contribute to armed forces? how many does south contribute?

do they complain why they have to take care of security?

as a nation every1 should contribute in what they are good at and just give  deaf ear to dumb dcikheads who talk this north south sh1t

[manadonga]

41 minutes ago, batman2 said:

2. BJP got most south indian seats and votes in the last election and has a pan south presence (3/5)

i already posted this several times stll some dumb dciks dont relaise reality.

BJP is not a north party

Bjp ki south lo enni vachhayi 

ap tamilanadu kerala kalipi zero 

congress ki ap lo zero 

[AntheKada]

Maha  Rashtra + South India = 80% of India GDP  anduke padi undali

[jathin]

40 minutes ago, batman2 said:

4. how much does north contribute to armed forces? how many does south contribute?

do they complain why they have to take care of security?

as a nation every1 should contribute in what they are good at and just give  deaf ear to dumb dcikheads who talk this north south sh1t

Nuvvu yedhoo thelivaina argument chesaaru anukuntunnavemo ... asalu South Indian states tax contribution yekkuva vunnappudu ... budget allocations lo kooda prominence vundaali ... Anthee gaani eee boku peeda mohaala Bodi and Banda shah only Gujarat and UP lo mathraame yekkuva budget allocation chesthunnaru.

Gujarat lo 1 lakh crore dholera city construction, 33k crores sardar Patel statue, Inko 1 lakh crores tho (Japan funding tho .. 0% or nominal interest tho) Bullet trains dheniki allocate chesaaru ... why isn’t any south or East Indians states not eligible 

[pahelwan]

Yes anduke visionary leader chapindu ekkuva mandi filagandlani kanumani. Pulkas full trying to increase fulkas population

[tom bhayya]

1 minute ago, jathin said:

Nuvvu yedhoo thelivaina argument chesaaru anukuntunnavemo ... asalu South Indian states tax contribution yekkuva vunnappudu ... budget allocations lo kooda prominence vundaali ... Anthee gaani eee boku peeda mohaala Bodi and Banda shah only Gujarat and UP lo mathraame yekkuva budget allocation chesthunnaru.

Gujarat lo 1 lakh crore dholera city construction, 33k crores sardar Patel statue, Inko 1 lakh crores tho (Japan funding tho .. 0% or nominal interest tho) Bullet trains dheniki allocate chesaaru ... why isn’t any south or East Indians states not eligible 

coz you are not voting us to fower , votes veyyanollaki dabbulu endhuku iyyala 

[hyperbole]

1 hour ago, Android_Halwa said:

The arguement of states contributing for center anedi oka invalid arguement.

Just because a state os contributing more , that means that state is earning more and makes sense to make a bit more contribution to aid other states.

 

Idi emaina HUF leka muslim personal law kadu, evadi vaatalu vaadiki ivadaniki...idi Government, profit and non profit gurinchi chepadaniki provate companiy kadu...welfare chusdalsindi Government.

Southern India la water shortage aye scope chala ekuva vundi, Northern Plains is excess..repati dinam interlinking tho mahanadi-godavari-krishna-kaveri link chesthe, mari arou kuda ie arguement chesthara ? 

No state can live completely on their own...there is not even one state which can sustain completely on its own with its own resources, for most goods and services, inter state trade is very important and as long as all these exist, arguements like I am contributing more to taxes ane vaadana bekaar muchata...

Nobody is arguing that center shouldn’t take a cut,  it is not about BJP vs Congress or the center, irrespective of who is at the top the tax devolutions are utter crap in my opinion.

even KA CM is complaining because in 2020-2021 they got a 8k crores cut in their tax devolution which is something we are talking about . What justifies UP receiving  18% and Bihar 9%? 27% Between 30 crore population and remaining 75% between 110 crore population? In what way is that justified when they are not even contributing that much
 

 

[manadonga]

1 minute ago, hyperbole said:

Nobody is arguing that center shouldn’t take a cut, even KA CM is complaining because in 2020-2021 they got a 8k crores cut in the tax devolution which is something we are talking about. What justifies UP receiving  18% and Bihar 9%? Just 27% Between 30 crore population and remaining 75% between 110 crore population? In what is that justified?
 

 

Modi pm ayyaka marchadu 

2019 inka tagginchadu south states ki 

[Marsmangalodu]

@TrollBait ochhi ee thread ni pavanam cheyyali ani naa manavi

[Android_Halwa]

3 minutes ago, hyperbole said:

Nobody is arguing that center shouldn’t take a cut,  it is not about BJP vs Congress, irrespective of who is at the top the tax devolutions are utter crap in my opinion.

even KA CM is complaining because in 2020-2021 they got a 8k crores cut in their tax devolution which is something we are talking about. What justifies UP receiving  18% and Bihar 9%? Just 27% Between 30 crore population and remaining 75% between 110 crore population? In what is that justified?
 

 

The situation of life standards and welfare state justifies the notion.

Imagine two states, Say Maharastra and Uttar Pradesh. Ok what basis do you think share of taxes should be decided ? 
 

Every state contributes and gets back the same amount contributed, what is the need to contribute then? It’s not United States of India, It’s Union of India. This should explain a lot of things. 

[Android_Halwa]

Progressive states should contribute more to backward states and this is the reason why we have the concept of Federal and state and each have their own governances and jurisdictions. 
 

If we don’t contribute more to UP and Bihar and AP, when will they develop ? If they had to do develop on their own, It will take centuries and progressive states will become wealthier and play the cards, Do you justify this ? Being born in different states will decide the fate whether they get to have access to welfare or not including education....Is this justified?

[Android_Halwa]

Look at Jharkhand...They are supplying coal to the nation, Iron ore, copper..Why should they supply ? Government of India owned companies do the mining here and contribute to deve eyes in Delhi but not Ranchi...

A coal, iron ore motham India use chesindi...Did we pay any royalty to Jharkhand? When we demand right share in the taxes, then we should start paying for royalties to other state’s resources too..

[Hydrockers]

CA kuda US nunchi divide avvochu antava