India's Agriculture reforms: is it good or bad for Farmers??? Poll

[Boomer]

Ebills lo main fault MSP ante minimum support price undedhi govt control o

Now after this bill no MSP it private odu entha chebithe anthake amali

That is beneficial to consumers but farmers ki kastam

[Boomer]

Overall good bills , liberalisation of 1991 was happening now in agriculture

[vaakel_saab]

last ki bheshma movie lekk ayithadi. 

BJP Mottam one nation policy tho emo chesettu unnaru.

• Education policy
• one ration card
• Electric bill
• GST 
• States ni dummy cheyalani chustunnru.. not good for INDIA

[tom brady]

3 minutes ago, vaakel_saab said:

last ki bheshma movie lekk ayithadi. 

BJP Mottam one nation policy tho emo chesettu unnaru.

• Education policy
• one ration card
• Electric bill
• GST 
• States ni dummy cheyalani chustunnru.. not good for INDIA

Lyt...our hindu pride would win

[Pappu_Packitmaar]

I can see exploitation in this bill, well it is part of the business and commerce and this is how it is and this is how it will be..exploitation has been there and will be there and very less  can be done to control it.

But I can also see trade between the states to be seamless, which I believe will be the positive sign.

MSP in its present form is anti-market. Farmers need to produce to be produced as per demand and it should    be the new norm and we need to get used to it.

[Ryzen_renoir]

3 minutes ago, Pappu_Packitmaar said:

I can see exploitation in this bill, well it is part of the business and commerce and this is how it is and this is how it will be..exploitation has been there and will be there and very less  can be done to control it.

But I can also see trade between the states to be seamless, which I believe will be the positive sign.

MSP in its present form is anti-market. Farmers need to produce to be produced as per demand and it should    be the new norm and we need to get used to it.

Boss india lo farmers are small and segregated by law due to land ceiling . How can a farmer of even 30 acres negotiate with Adani ? 

Our police ask for bribe even for theft cases , our courts are sold out to the highest bidder . There will be no justice to farmers without strong legal protections in place.    

Some of the provisions are fine  but there are no safeguards regarding MSP in this bill at all . Reforms are good but screwing farmers for the benefit of coorporates is draconian . 

Do you think any court can touch mukesh Ambani or Adani today ?

[Gnan_anna]

3 hours ago, Gaali_Gottam_Govinda said:

The government has undertaken landmark agricultural reforms, freeing farmers from restrictions on sale of their produce and ending the monopoly of traders. It has also opened the window for private capital by allowing farmers to enter into deals with large buyers such as exporters and retailers.

This is expected to catalyse the sector, bring in much-needed private investment and boost rural incomes. Here’s a look at key measures in the legislation passed in Lok Sabha.
 

 

 

Mee Opinion enti???............. Hope this bill will help real farmers. 

Kotha ga emledhu va ...politicians and middlemen nexus poyi politicians and corporate nexus osthadhi...ee bill ki support chesthey parties and oppose chesey parties iddariki vested interests unnayi...final ga bokka padedhi farmers ke...centralisation of looting is the agenda of central party ...dhanni oppose chesthunna regional parties...

[tom bhayya]

దిల్లీ: రాజ్యసభలో కేంద్ర ప్రభుత్వం ప్రవేశపెట్టిన వ్యవసాయ బిల్లులకు వైకాపా మద్దతిచ్చింది. వ్యవసాయ బిల్లులపై రాజ్యసభలో చర్చ సందర్భంగా ఆ పార్టీ ఎంపీ విజయసాయిరెడ్డి మాట్లాడుతూ... గతంలో దళారీల దయాదాక్షిణ్యాలపై రైతులు బతికారని, ఈ బిల్లుల ద్వారా గిట్టుబాటు ధర దక్కుతుందన్నారు. నచ్చినచోట పంట అమ్ముకోవడం వల్ల రైతులకు లబ్ధి చేకూరుతుందన్నారు. ఏపీలో రైతు భరోసా పథకం ద్వారా సీఎం చరిత్రాత్మక నిర్ణయం తీసుకుంటున్నారని విజయసాయిరెడ్డి చెప్పారు.

‘‘రాత్రింబవళ్లు కష్టపడి పంటలు పండించిన రైతులు ప్రధానంగా రెండు సమస్యలు ఎదుర్కొంటున్నారు. మొదటిది రైతులకు సరైన మద్దతు ధర లభించడం లేదు. రెండోది రైతులు పండించిన పంటను గిట్టుబాటు ధరకు అమ్ముకోలేని పరిస్థితి ఉంది. ఈ బిల్లు ద్వారా ముందుగా నిర్ణయించుకున్న ధరకు రైతులు పంట అమ్ముకునే వీలుంది. వ్యవసాయ మార్కెట్లు రైతులకు గిట్టుబాటు ధర కల్పించడంలేదు. మధ్య వర్తుల వల్ల రైతులు నష్టపోతున్నారు. గిట్టుబాటు ధర వచ్చిన చోట పంట విక్రయం వల్ల రైతులకు లబ్ధి చేకూరుతుంది’’ అని విజయసాయిరెడ్డి పేర్కొన్నారు.

[tom bhayya]

VSR garu bill support chesaaru mukkodiki mind ledhu opposing antunna @Hydrockers

[tom bhayya]

దిల్లీ: కేంద్ర ప్రభుత్వం తెచ్చిన వ్యవసాయ బిల్లుతో రైతులకు తీరని నష్టం వాటిల్లే ప్రమాదముందని తెరాస ఎంపీ కె.కేశవరావు ఆందోళన వ్యక్తం చేశారు. రాజ్యసభలో వ్యవసాయ అనుబంధ బిల్లులపై చర్చ సందర్భంగా కేశవరావు మాట్లాడుతూ... మార్కెటింగ్‌ ఏజెంట్లకు కూడా నష్టం చేసేలా కొత్త చట్టం ఉందన్నారు. వ్యవసాయంలో కూడా కార్పొరేట్లను పెంచి పోషించేలా ఉందని పేర్కొన్నారు. ‘‘ఒక్కో క్లస్టర్‌లో 1.65 లక్షల మంది రైతులు ఉన్నారు. కేంద్ర ఏ పథకానికీ సరిగా నిధులు ఇవ్వడం లేదు. వ్యవసాయం, సంబంధిత అంశాలు ఎప్పుడూ రాష్ట్ర పరిధిలోనే ఉండాలి. ఈ కొత్త చట్టం రైతులకు అండగా నిలిచేలా లేదు’’  అని కేశవరావు స్పష్టం చేశారు.

[Pappu_Packitmaar]

1 hour ago, Boomer said:

Overall good bills , liberalisation of 1991 was happening now in agriculture

That true.

May be the system needs a shake up...I will not say this is the right system but with present system, it’s tough to go into future.

Help chestado ledo time will tell but will shake up existing system, then things fall in place.

2-4 years of disturbance for sure..

[Pappu_Packitmaar]

56 minutes ago, Ryzen_renoir said:

Boss india lo farmers are small and segregated by law due to land ceiling . How can a farmer of even 30 acres negotiate with Adani ? 

Our police ask for bribe even for theft cases , our courts are sold out to the highest bidder . There will be no justice to farmers without strong legal protections in place.    

Some of the provisions are fine  but there are no safeguards regarding MSP in this bill at all . Reforms are good but screwing farmers for the benefit of coorporates is draconian . 

Do you think any court can touch mukesh Ambani or Adani today ?

Here is the bigger underlying problem.

Agri land owners’s land holding is getting smaller...for example, a medium sized farmer if he had 10 acres, and by the time it is passed over to next gen, say split into two sons, they will inherit 5 acres each. Now do you think the input costs and earnings from 5 acre plot will be on par with 10 acres?

This demographic change has been happening and medium size farmer of 20 years back is now a small size farmer. Inputs costs are rising and there is a need for additional investment to make it profitable.

[tom bhayya]

Urgent ga oka godown chusukovaali kandhi pappu koni pettukovaali 

[Pappu_Packitmaar]

Just now, Pappu_Packitmaar said:

Here is the bigger underlying problem.

Agri land owners’s land holding is getting smaller...for example, a medium sized farmer if he had 10 acres, and by the time it is passed over to next gen, say split into two sons, they will inherit 5 acres each. Now do you think the input costs and earnings from 5 acre plot will be on par with 10 acres?

This demographic change has been happening and medium size farmer of 20 years back is now a small size farmer. Inputs costs are rising and there is a need for additional investment to make it profitable.

A farmer harvests the crop and yet has no idea who the buyer is. This is the gap.

Banks are providing loan for now...but instead of banks if private corporations or business provide loans as part of investment strategy, that would make farmers a main part of supply chain system with minimum assurances. There is a scope for exploitation but that’s always there.

[Pappu_Packitmaar]

More and more land is coming into cultivation, accessibility to power and machinery is getting easier and affordable by each day, mechanized agriculture is gaining prominence, more ayacut is being stabilised...

If the same kind of crop output predicted, then the market will witness over production and collapse of MSP based incentive market.

Let get people who can sell things better, let’s get people who can market the produce, let’s get people into the system who can invest and improve the logistics and procurement and provide a market and supplement procurement and create a new supply chain system....We are living in a capitalistic society but why do we still think Adani or Ambani are really bad for the society ?