Healthy discussion. Reservation candidates in India

[veerigadu]

Upliftment varaku I get it. 

But generations after generations reservation use chesukoni malli enduku thokalu and pilakalu theeseyalli ani why expect sestharu myaaan. 

Oka certain status vacchaka you denounce reservation and then higher cassettes will give up their thokaluuuuu.

Anthe gani 10ngi kotlu sampadinchi malli school lo join chesetappudu koduku ki cassette certificate kosam line lo nilabade batch chill avvandi ra royyaaa.

As long as reservations are intact the concept of hierarchy and stereotypes will stay on. 

 

[Anta Assamey]

Who doesn't want when someone is being given something at a discounted percentage or for free due to the history... Why would anyone disagree with their own advantage...

[tom bhayya]

6 minutes ago, veerigadu said:

Upliftment varaku I get it. 

But generations after generations reservation use chesukoni malli enduku thokalu and pilakalu theeseyalli ani why expect sestharu myaaan. 

Oka certain status vacchaka you denounce reservation and then higher cassettes will give up their thokaluuuuu.

Anthe gani 10ngi kotlu sampadinchi malli school lo join chesetappudu koduku ki cassette certificate kosam line lo nilabade batch chill avvandi ra royyaaa.

As long as reservations are intact the concept of hierarchy and stereotypes will stay on. 

 

Anna vomerica lo eb1 eb2 eb3 eb5 or marriage or mavni ila rules use chesukuni advantage theesukuney manam vallani aa question adagodhu anna , vaadukunnodiki vaadukunnantha as simple as that

[kevinUsa]

Following

[kalaa_pipaasi]

13 minutes ago, veerigadu said:

Oka certain status vacchaka you denounce reservation

that has to come from individual's thinking process. ika chalu ani evarina enduku anukuntaru..?govt reserv isthundi ga vadukodam lo thappemundi..its as per law anthe.

[Ryzen_renoir]

22 minutes ago, veerigadu said:

Upliftment varaku I get it. 

But generations after generations reservation use chesukoni malli enduku thokalu and pilakalu theeseyalli ani why expect sestharu myaaan. 

Oka certain status vacchaka you denounce reservation and then higher cassettes will give up their thokaluuuuu.

Anthe gani 10ngi kotlu sampadinchi malli school lo join chesetappudu koduku ki cassette certificate kosam line lo nilabade batch chill avvandi ra royyaaa.

As long as reservations are intact the concept of hierarchy and stereotypes will stay on. 

 

I don't have problem with reservation itself but main problem with it is its benefits are only reaching very few successive generations of families . 

Same family successive generations  reservation lo jobs chestunaru . The really poor and downtrodden are being ignored 

Creamy layer should be strictly enforced to ensure that really poor get it's benefits 

[veerigadu]

1 hour ago, tom bhayya said:

Anna vomerica lo eb1 eb2 eb3 eb5 or marriage or mavni ila rules use chesukuni advantage theesukuney manam vallani aa question adagodhu anna , vaadukunnodiki vaadukunnantha as simple as that

Keyword "deserving" anna. Also your anology is out of context. Not sure what you are trying to tell here. 

[veerigadu]

1 hour ago, Ryzen_renoir said:

I don't have problem with reservation itself but main problem with it is its benefits are only reaching very few successive generations of families . 

 

Tinnitus? when the Ringing Won't Stop, Do...

healthtoday

 

 

 

Same family successive generations  reservation lo jobs chestunaru . The really poor and downtrodden are being ignored 

 

 

Creamy layer should be strictly enforced to ensure that really poor get it's benefits 

Exactly. Just cos you are born into certain cassettteeee shouldnt default qualify you for reservation.

If you want to enjoy the good part of the stick then dont complain and preach about the not so good part of casteismmmm.

Its hypocrisy.

Either embrace or denounce it completely..Dont stand halfway across the street to reap only benefits.  

[Ryzen_renoir]

9 minutes ago, veerigadu said:

Exactly. Just cos you are born into certain cassettteeee shouldnt default qualify you for reservation.

If you want to enjoy the good part of the stick then dont complain and preach about the not so good part of casteismmmm.

Its hypocrisy.

Either embrace or denounce it completely..Dont stand halfway across the street to reap only benefits.  

Sadly all the intellectual discourse regarding reservation is hijacked by same people who greatly benefit from it . 

It's a politically sensitive matter , the solution must come up from dalit community itself

[veerigadu]

28 minutes ago, Ryzen_renoir said:

Sadly all the intellectual discourse regarding reservation is hijacked by same people who greatly benefit from it . 

It's a politically sensitive matter , the solution must come up from dalit community itself

Reservation is touchy subject for many folks. Whoever questions it faces the wrath of kula sanghalu.

[ChinnaBhasha]

after rapid urbanization, thokalu are lite man.. Anybody can keep whatever thoka they want, and you will see that in future. 

Nen CLG lo unapude ma batchmate okadu undevadu who's from sc and with rao thoka

[Ryzen_renoir]

13 minutes ago, ChinnaBhasha said:

after rapid urbanization, thokalu are lite man.. Anybody can keep whatever thoka they want, and you will see that in future. 

Nen CLG lo unapude ma batchmate okadu undevadu who's from sc and with rao thoka

Plenty of Sc/ST have reddy title too , ex min geeta reddy is an example

[ChinnaBhasha]

Just now, Ryzen_renoir said:

Plenty of Sc/ST have reddy title too , ex min geeta reddy is an example

yes, sc st people will be encouraged more in future to have thokas

[Ryzen_renoir]

11 minutes ago, ChinnaBhasha said:

yes, sc st people will be encouraged more in future to have thokas

It still doesn't change anything 

[Telugodura456]

Reservations are not meant for help/upliftment  gatra gatra. it is meant for REPRESENTATION. so it doesnt matter how much money/help the community has .

IN normal societies which do not have caste, income and self effort are good markers of future success and there is no need for mandatory quotas.

But Indian society historically to modern times more or less does not have the capability to evaluate an individual as individual. It is always caste. For centuries it suppressed 90 plus population to take up demeaning jobs such as cleaning latrines or hard/tough jobs like farming while other 10 percent happily enjoyed leisure jobs of trading/priests with abracadabara mantar jantar with mandatory dakshinas from kings and every one etc.

And unless you force these people will behave exactly in the same way. Govt does not interfere with private sector. where is representation for sc/st/ or farmers there? look at hindi media especially - do you see any anchor/media pundit coming from opressed castes ?