Article 370: India trying to prevent declassification of ‘sensitive’ 1947 Kashmir papers

[JackSeal]

1 minute ago, JaiBalayyaaa said:

Kashmir is an integral part of India. Answer with true or false. We know the rest of the story. 

As per instrument of accession Kashmir was integral part of India from 26th Oct 1947. Kashmir was a separate country from 15th August 1947 to 26th Oct 1947. 
Go by facts not by assumptions.

[JaiBalayyaaa]

1 minute ago, JackSeal said:

As per instrument of accession Kashmir was integral part of India from 26th Oct 1947. Kashmir was a separate country from 15th August 1947 to 26th Oct 1947. 
Go by facts not by assumptions.

My question is Kashmir IS an integral part of India, not was. Read and answer. 

[JackSeal]

Just now, JaiBalayyaaa said:

My question is Kashmir IS an integral part of India, not was. Read and answer. 

Come to point. Ignore grammar.

Go by facts not by assumptions. 

[gattimelam]

6 minutes ago, JackSeal said:

As per instrument of accession Kashmir was integral part of India from 26th Oct 1947. Kashmir was a separate country from 15th August 1947 to 26th Oct 1947. 
Go by facts not by assumptions.

[kingcasanova]

21 minutes ago, JackSeal said:

He didn’t keep them confidential… they are with UK archives and classified. That is the reason why I told to Google and read more about Bucher Papers. Few of those papers were given to India in 1970 by Bucher.

UK chethilo alaanti papers ye ganuka undunte, eee paatiki eppudooo release chese vaaallu, they like to 10ng us back and forth no?

[JackSeal]

Just now, kingcasanova said:

UK chethilo alaanti papers ye ganuka undunte, eee paatiki eppudooo release chese vaaallu, they like to 10ng us back and forth no?

https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/a8a4a001-f5b4-4215-86ee-33781fb931ba

[chammakchandra]

1 hour ago, JackSeal said:

Indian government is trying to stall the declassification of a collection of documents from 1947, known as the Bucher Papers, over fears that its contents could affect foreign relations. The documents are believed to contain “political and military arguments” related to why India’s first prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru decided to grant Kashmir special status under Article 370, it says.

Malli c o n g I gallu vasthey k a s h ni p a k I gallaku echestharu

[JaiBalayyaaa]

10 minutes ago, JackSeal said:

Come to point. Ignore grammar.

Go by facts not by assumptions. 

By facts, is Kashmir an integral part of India? 

[JackSeal]

1 minute ago, JaiBalayyaaa said:

By facts, is Kashmir an integral part of India? 

is integral part of India from 26th October 1947.

Come to point now and answer:

When did pakistan occupied part of Kashmir ?

[JaiBalayyaaa]

Just now, JackSeal said:

is integral part of India from 26th October 1947.

Come to point now and answer:

When did pakistan occupied part of Kashmir ?

1949 

[JackSeal]

3 minutes ago, JaiBalayyaaa said:

1949 

Wrong

24 October 1947: Pakistani militants invaded Kashmir and occupied part of Kashmir

24 October 1947: Maharaja requested military assistance and proposed accession to India.

25 October 1947: On Maharaja request VP Menon was sent to Kashmir to assess the situation.

26 October 1947: V. P. Menon brought news that the situation in Kashmir was critical and that the Maharaja was ready to agree to "any terms". 

26 October 1947 – 27 October 1947: The Maharaja signed the Instrument of Accession.

27 October 1947: The Indian army entered the state to repel the invaders.

 

[JaiBalayyaaa]

6 minutes ago, JackSeal said:

Wrong

24 October 1947: Pakistani militants invaded Kashmir and occupied part of Kashmir

24 October 1947: Maharaja requested military assistance and proposed accession to India.

25 October 1947: On Maharaja request VP Menon was sent to Kashmir to assess the situation.

26 October 1947: V. P. Menon brought news that the situation in Kashmir was critical and that the Maharaja was ready to agree to "any terms". 

26 October 1947 – 27 October 1947: The Maharaja signed the Instrument of Accession.

27 October 1947: The Indian army entered the state to repel the invaders.

 

And in 1949: Pakistan took Azad Kashmir and called it self governing. 

[kingcasanova]

29 minutes ago, JackSeal said:

https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/a8a4a001-f5b4-4215-86ee-33781fb931ba

inkem mari ayithe publish chesirru gaa, malli endhi eee panchayithi

[Spartan]

 thanks anna

2024 ki emaina jumla trick dorkutada leda ani alochistunte meere start chesettunnaru

@ZoomNaidu

[JackSeal]

1 minute ago, JaiBalayyaaa said:

And in 1949: Pakistan took Azad Kashmir and called it self governing. 

Azad Kashmir was founded on 24th October 1947 by rebels with Pakistani help. From 1947 to 1949 Indian forces led by British commanding officers are fighting with rebels, defended few areas but never regained control of current POK. Azad Kashmir signed aggrement with Pak in 1949. Bucher is one top general. And he wrote to Nehru that their forces are tired  and asked to seek a political solution rather than military solution. Bucher papers are about these sequence of communications between army and govt.

That is when cease fire and UN intervention happened.