Article 370: India trying to prevent declassification of ‘sensitive’ 1947 Kashmir papers

[JaiBalayyaaa]

8 minutes ago, JackSeal said:

army gives up how govt will seek a military solution ?

Does he have it in writing that the army gave up? Show one person in the army who will attest to what you're saying? 

[bhaigan]

6 minutes ago, odhu_le_macha said:

 

India pak enduk devide aindi thelus ga and enduk Paki gallu separate state ichina vellakunda Kashmir lo unnaru... Kashmir pandits ni champi muslim majority ani prove cheskuni referendum ani edo try chesthunnaru.. yedi emaina Nehru gadu UN ki e matter tiskupovadam thappu.. Internal matter idi...  Country strong ga lekunde a party vasthe em undi.. ippudu konchamm better undi anni countries tho relation compare to congis...

UN is monitoring agency of the world. Nehru tisukellakapothe Pak tisukelli false narratives ni cook chesedi emo

Anni countries lo strong ga undataniki BJP vachi podichindi emi ledu, previous prime ministers hard work valu vellina UP's and Down's valla country ee situation lo undi

[odhu_le_macha]

Just now, bhaigan said:

UN is monitoring agency of the world. Nehru tisukellakapothe Pak tisukelli false narratives ni cook chesthadi emo

Anni countries lo strong ga undataniki BJP vachi podichindi emi ledu, previous prime ministers hard work valu vellina UP's and Down's valla country is in this situation

Paki gadu tiskelladam veru Indian PM gade tikelladam veru...Un world police antavu... Em peekindi aithe poor counries meda US attach chesthe...Ipppudu Ukraine and Russia matter lo em chesthundi.. World politics ki bali aitham country week unte...

 

[bhaigan]

3 minutes ago, JaiBalayyaaa said:

Does he have it in writing that the army gave up? Show one person in the army who will attest to what you're saying? 

Ante appatlo Kashmir kosam desam lo unna youth motham chachipovala. There will be at one peak of point where peace agreements will be happen. It is not giving up

[JaiBalayyaaa]

2 minutes ago, bhaigan said:

Ante appatlo Kashmir kosam desam lo unna youth motham chachipovala. There will be at one peak of point where peace agreements will be happen. It is not giving up

 

2 minutes ago, bhaigan said:

Ante appatlo Kashmir kosam desam lo unna youth motham chachipovala. There will be at one peak of point where peace agreements will be happen. It is not giving up

Like I said Indian army gave up ani statement ichinda

[bhaigan]

9 minutes ago, odhu_le_macha said:

Paki gadu tiskelladam veru Indian PM gade tikelladam veru...Un world police antavu... Em peekindi aithe poor counries meda US attach chesthe...Ipppudu Ukraine and Russia matter lo em chesthundi.. World politics ki bali aitham country week unte...

 

Ukraine eppudo destroy ayipoyi undalsindi powerful nuke country ayina russia ni direct attack chesthe WWIII ne vasthadi , they dealt it in very tactical way thats the reason Ukraine survived till now. And G20 meet happened in Bali, Indonesia supported Ukraine. Nee perception edo okati pettuko kani Nehru didn't do anything wrong 

[bhaigan]

1 minute ago, JaiBalayyaaa said:

 

Like I said Indian army gave up ani statement ichinda

It is not giving up at one point of time there will be peace agreements

[JaiBalayyaaa]

Just now, bhaigan said:

It is not giving up at one point of time there will be peace agreements

Not when BJP is in power ani Amit Shah annadanuko, who do you think people will believe? 

[odhu_le_macha]

2 minutes ago, bhaigan said:

Ukraine eppudo destroy ayipoyi undalsindi powerful nuke country ayina russia ni direct attack chesthe WWIII ne vasthadi , they dealt it in very tactical way thats the reason Ukraine survived till now. That's reason G20 meet happened in Bali, Indonesia and supported Ukraine. Nee perception edo okati pettuko kani Nehru didn't do anything wrong 

anthe antav...em chesina slave mentality tho anni countries undali UN correct ga chesthadi ani..nice.

[odhu_le_macha]

Nehru GIFTED the Kabo Valley (Manipur, 11,000+ sq. km.) to Burma.

Was it his ancestral property, to
Burma paid a monthly lease for the Kabo Valley until 1949. After that, with Nehru's consent, it stopped paying & annexed the valley.

Nehru did not take Parliament's consent for this act. Congress-dominated Parliament did not intervene, nor did later governments.

[bhaigan]

1 minute ago, odhu_le_macha said:

anthe antav...em chesina slave mentality tho anni countries undali UN correct ga chesthadi ani..nice.

slave mentality Gujarat BJP IT cell lo manufacture ayye venom spitting , fake propaganda's promote chese vallaki untadi

[JackSeal]

1 minute ago, JaiBalayyaaa said:

Does he have it in writing that the army gave up? Show one person in the army who will attest to what you're saying? 

See from 1947 to 1949 army is not only defending Kashmir but also fighting with pakistan for Junagad, Fighting with Nizam in Hyderabad, likewise at many places. Kashmir is one of thousands of critical issues which new nation is working on. Since all thousand issues are irrelevant now you are thinking only Kashmir.

Bucher papers are not available online but people can read them in some London library. In India they were classified and treated as sensitive. 

“Roy Bucher suggested a political approach to solve the escalating situation given military fatigue faced by Indian troops due to 13 months of military deployment, including taking the matter before the United Nations,” the source said.

Before military gives up making things worse and based on commander in cheif feedback govt took political approach.

[bhaigan]

Just now, odhu_le_macha said:

Nehru GIFTED the Kabo Valley (Manipur, 11,000+ sq. km.) to Burma.

Was it his ancestral property, to
Burma paid a monthly lease for the Kabo Valley until 1949. After that, with Nehru's consent, it stopped paying & annexed the valley.

Nehru did not take Parliament's consent for this act. Congress-dominated Parliament did not intervene, nor did later governments.

India ede ani cheppadaniki oka shape or akaram em ledu, it is evolution of humanity and cross cultures

Back then India was spread till Afghanistan, ante ippudu afghan part of India antava

[odhu_le_macha]

3 minutes ago, bhaigan said:

slave mentality Gujarat BJP IT cell lo manufacture ayye venom spitting , fake propaganda's promote chese vallaki untadi

parties gurinchi vadiley .. Historivcal mistakes ivi

[JackSeal]

15 minutes ago, odhu_le_macha said:

Paki gadu tiskelladam veru Indian PM gade tikelladam veru...Un world police antavu... Em peekindi aithe poor counries meda US attach chesthe...Ipppudu Ukraine and Russia matter lo em chesthundi.. World politics ki bali aitham country week unte...

 

 Bipan Chandra noted in his book that claiming the move to approach United Nations as a fault is totally a wrong perspective because if Nehru had not gone to the UN, Pakistan would have gone first. But these Bucher papers, which have been classified for long, reveals that there was actually no possibility of further military option, as corresponded by the then commander-in-chief, Gen Sir Francis Robert Roy Bucher:

“Army personnel evince two weaknesses, lack of training in the junior leaders, tiredness and ennui in the other ranks … In brief, the army needs respite for leave, training, and vitalising.” 

The war ended on 1 January 1949 with a ceasefire arranged by the United Nations.