h4 ead case @ supreme court

[BacklogBadham]

H4 EAD or OPT extention or DACA was not EO lu. EO lepadam chala easy but not rule masking. All please just get your facts right. Just for education purpose only 😜 New ga vache H1B wage based kuda rule making not done random EO same with lottery system. Hope all understand the difference 

The H4 EAD (Employment Authorization Document) was established through rule making, not an executive order. Here are the key details:

Rule Making Process

The H4 EAD program was created through the formal federal regulatory process:

• May 12, 2014: DHS proposed the rule and opened it for public comments

• February 25, 2015: DHS finalized the rule after reviewing comments and making minor revisions

• May 26, 2015: The final rule became effective, allowing eligible H4 spouses to apply for work authorization

Legal Framework

The rule was published as a final regulation by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) under the Immigration and Nationality Act. This regulation extended eligibility for employment authorization to certain H4 dependent spouses of H1B nonimmigrants who are seeking employment-based lawful permanent resident status.

Not an Executive Order

While some sources mention that H4 EAD, like DACA, was "created through executive action" and is therefore vulnerable to elimination through new executive orders, this appears to reference the Obama administration's broader immigration policy approach rather than the specific legal mechanism. The H4 EAD was actually established through the standard federal rulemaking process, which includes:

• Public notice and comment periods

• Review by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB)

• Publication in the Federal Register

• Administrative procedures compliance

This distinction is important because regulations created through formal rulemaking typically require the same process to be modified or rescinded, whereas executive orders can be more easily changed by subsequent administrations.

[fasak_vachadu]

1 hour ago, akkum_bakkum said:

Antha ledu..it went through rule making process under the proper authority of president. It has to be repealed with the same rule making process. Surprisingly this administration is not interested in repealing this. Every lower court sided with govt stating it went through proper legal process and thy dont have the authority. Most than likely supreme court may also side with govt. Save jobs usa can still win this thru pressuring the administration to initiate the repeal process.

ledu anna Eo dawara vachindi .... bama uncle kukka biscuit vesadu ....

 

ippudu desi lawyers will start chanda collecting money 

[BacklogBadham]

5 minutes ago, JohnyGalt said:

DOJ is  supporting the EO, just to assert their authority to do EOs. That does not mean they wanted it. They can go ahead later and get it revoked with another EO.

Not EO rule making. Adhi theeyali ante enkoka rule making ravali. EO lepadam rule making lepadam chala difference undhi bro. Monna birthright citizenship EO lo lepestham annantha comedy edhi. All do tinepass for fans. Nothing much. They had their sweet 4 years rule making ki but they didn't now considering it but it will take 1 year at least rule making ki 

[mettastar]

1 hour ago, CanadianMalodu said:

 

https://www.uscis.gov/archive/dhs-extends-eligibility-for-employment-authorization-to-certain-h-4-dependent-spouses-of-h-1b?

Ob0z0 EO isthene jarigindhi. Lekapothe antha bomma ledhu. Proper authority aa? Adenti? 

Rule revoke cheyyalante adhi executive action. Asalu EO overreach ani SCOTUS lo vasthe (leave lobbying effects aside, okavela) then default strike down, no rule making thokka totakoora. 

DHS implemented it through rule making process, which involves collecting feedback from public..  18months process anukunta .. rule finalize ayye time lo obama gadu along with DACA idi kuda announce chesadu .. but this went through proper rule making process. You can search

[BacklogBadham]

Just now, fasak_vachadu said:

ledu anna Eo dawara vachindi .... bama uncle kukka biscuit vesadu ....

 

ippudu desi lawyers will start chanda collecting money 

Bro adhi EO kadhu Federal rule making. Chala misunderstanding undi andariki e programs lo 

Asalu story cheptha vinu what happened anedhi. 

Gang of of 8 ani senators oka immigration reform bill pass chesaru but unfortunately House lo Republican speaker didn't bring it for the vote lekunte pass ayyedhi be cause it was passed in the senate after many negotiations. So chesedhi emi leka Obama DACA ni save cheyyadaniki EO kakunda broader immigration executive actions ani means EO echadu proper plan cheyyandi ani means EO lo cheppadu rule making cheyyamanu DHS ki anthe kani pen tho EO meedha sign cheyyaledhu DACA and H4 EAD echeyandi ani. Ala ayyunte eppudo H4 EAD or DACA lechi poyevi. Obama is not dhadhamma he knew some republican will strike down ani so proper rule making chepunchadu DHS tho. Dhaniki process Google lo chudu. Eppudu manam chusthunna H1B lottery changes kuda rule making ne. Chala difference untundhi bro rule making ki EO. EO no you can strike off right away but rule making you can't dhaniki you should bring another rule making changes like now H1B wage level from lottery. Hope all understood e issue ni 😊

[fasak_vachadu]

2 minutes ago, BacklogBadham said:

Bro adhi EO kadhu Federal rule making. Chala misunderstanding undi andariki e programs lo 

Asalu story cheptha vinu what happened anedhi. 

Gang of of 8 ani senators oka immigration reform bill pass chesaru but unfortunately House lo Republican speaker didn't bring it for the vote lekunte pass ayyedhi be cause it was passed in the senate after many negotiations. So chesedhi emi leka Obama DACA ni save cheyyadaniki EO kakunda broader immigration executive actions ani means EO echadu proper plan cheyyandi ani means EO lo cheppadu rule making cheyyamanu DHS ki anthe kani pen tho EO meedha sign cheyyaledhu DACA and H4 EAD echeyandi ani. Ala ayyunte eppudo H4 EAD or DACA lechi poyevi. Obama is not dhadhamma he knew some republican will strike down ani so proper rule making chepunchadu DHS tho. Dhaniki process Google lo chudu. Eppudu manam chusthunna H1B lottery changes kuda rule making ne. Chala difference untundhi bro rule making ki EO. EO no you can strike off right away but rule making you can't dhaniki you should bring another rule making changes like now H1B wage level from lottery. Hope all understood e issue ni 😊

so rules are made to break it antavu.... inkko rule petii lepi 10gutharu after that truck incident they got a sixer ball andaru edichi sastunaru tik tok lo twitter lo, face book lo 

even valla community leaders also affraid to support them.... anni gurudawra lo cameras tesukoni youtuber and video coneten makers making lot of nonses 

[JohnyGalt]

12 minutes ago, BacklogBadham said:

Not EO rule making. Adhi theeyali ante enkoka rule making ravali. EO lepadam rule making lepadam chala difference undhi bro. Monna birthright citizenship EO lo lepestham annantha comedy edhi. All do tinepass for fans. Nothing much. They had their sweet 4 years rule making ki but they didn't now considering it but it will take 1 year at least rule making ki 

EOs will go through rule making process to make them parmanent. I got it it.

In the new changed political landscape , it’s naive to think Trump administration will not come after this H4 ead.
I have strong feeling that once Ukraine deal collapses , this admin will come after H1B, H4EAD, OPT and tariffs on Indian IT services.

Modi government miscalculated and did a blunder by acting like China. The truth is India is not China and we are lazy and not that good with hard working engineering jobs.

More over the world politics are looking similar to pre WW2 times and global political landscape is about to go through a metamorphosis.

[bunk seenu]

14 minutes ago, BacklogBadham said:

Not EO rule making. Adhi theeyali ante enkoka rule making ravali. EO lepadam rule making lepadam chala difference undhi bro. Monna birthright citizenship EO lo lepestham annantha comedy edhi. All do tinepass for fans. Nothing much. They had their sweet 4 years rule making ki but they didn't now considering it but it will take 1 year at least rule making ki 

Avanni maaku teliyadanna... maaku manual testing tappithe emi raadu..aa jobs ki h4 ead vallu addu vastunaru.. so tiseyali ani korukuntunam...

[Tellugodu]

9 minutes ago, BacklogBadham said:

Bro adhi EO kadhu Federal rule making. Chala misunderstanding undi andariki e programs lo 

Asalu story cheptha vinu what happened anedhi. 

Gang of of 8 ani senators oka immigration reform bill pass chesaru but unfortunately House lo Republican speaker didn't bring it for the vote lekunte pass ayyedhi be cause it was passed in the senate after many negotiations. So chesedhi emi leka Obama DACA ni save cheyyadaniki EO kakunda broader immigration executive actions ani means EO echadu proper plan cheyyandi ani means EO lo cheppadu rule making cheyyamanu DHS ki anthe kani pen tho EO meedha sign cheyyaledhu DACA and H4 EAD echeyandi ani. Ala ayyunte eppudo H4 EAD or DACA lechi poyevi. Obama is not dhadhamma he knew some republican will strike down ani so proper rule making chepunchadu DHS tho. Dhaniki process Google lo chudu. Eppudu manam chusthunna H1B lottery changes kuda rule making ne. Chala difference untundhi bro rule making ki EO. EO no you can strike off right away but rule making you can't dhaniki you should bring another rule making changes like now H1B wage level from lottery. Hope all understood e issue ni 😊

Adantha kadu kani, H4 EAD eepudu lepestharu and H1b wage level eppudu implement aythundo cheppu.

[fasak_vachadu]

Just now, Tellugodu said:

Adantha kadu kani, H4 EAD eepudu lepestharu and H1b wage level eppudu implement aythundo cheppu.

inkko one year disco and malli e tarrif set aye varaku e disco untadi 

[perugu_vada]

Ivi emi antha fast ga implement avvavu .. but definite ga processing aithe delay chestaru .. 

will h4-ead be gone ah ante .. yes it will be .. not in immediate future like in next 1-2months .. but it takes about 2-yrs

[perugu_vada]

H4 ead is toxic especially in IT.. adi mathram nijam

ipudu mana desi Tejams .. management layer ki vellaru .. so definite ga desi gaalla ne theskuntunaru .. inka telisinolla ki ante preference istunaru .. so in a way h4-ead theseyatam is good in long run 

[BacklogBadham]

5 minutes ago, fasak_vachadu said:

so rules are made to break it antavu.... inkko rule petii lepi 10gutharu after that truck incident they got a sixer ball andaru edichi sastunaru tik tok lo twitter lo, face book lo 

even valla community leaders also affraid to support them.... anni gurudawra lo cameras tesukoni youtuber and video coneten makers making lot of nonses 

 

5 minutes ago, JohnyGalt said:

EOs will go through rule making process to make them parmanent. I got it it.

In the new changed political landscape , it’s naive to think Trump administration will not come after this H4 ead.
I have strong feeling that once Ukraine deal collapses , this admin will come after H1B, H4EAD, OPT and tariffs on Indian IT services.

Modi government miscalculated and did a blunder by acting like China. The truth is India is not China and we are lazy and not that good with hard working engineering jobs.

More over the world politics are looking similar to pre WW2 times and global political landscape is about to go through a metamorphosis.

They still have time lepadaniki. But intention undha Ledha or lobbying?  Courts tho lepdama rule making anedhi nonsense. Some don't know how things work here edho Trump nominate chesina judges will favor him ante nadavadhu USA. Birthright citizenship won't go anywhere that day they said President EO ki andaru okay anali anthe kani constitutional things EO tho lepestham ante every Trump and Biden will change things every 4 years with a pen. Then why do you need a congress or judicial system in USA. You can do presidential rule simple ga. Manam matladinatha easy kadhu bro things. TPS was different story H4 EAD was different story. TPS was congress Bill originally but Biden used his presedential power to extend certain countries under some Section 8 rule but same type Trump canceled it. 

Admin ki H4 EAD or OPT extension lepali ane thought vasthe yes they can make rule making original ki against ga. Lobbying matters here inside the white house 😊

[BacklogBadham]

6 minutes ago, perugu_vada said:

Ivi emi antha fast ga implement avvavu .. but definite ga processing aithe delay chestaru .. 

will h4-ead be gone ah ante .. yes it will be .. not in immediate future like in next 1-2months .. but it takes about 2-yrs

Yes they will apply delay tactics then they can make Corporate lobby happy and their fans happy. Same with GC process now numbers kanapadochu from FB to EB Spill over but they won't process either of them. Delay tactics comedy thing they will approve H1B premium chesthe immediate ga 😜

[futureofandhra]

4 minutes ago, BacklogBadham said:

 

They still have time lepadaniki. But intention undha Ledha or lobbying?  Courts tho lepdama rule making anedhi nonsense. Some don't know how things work here edho Trump nominate chesina judges will favor him ante nadavadhu USA. Birthright citizenship won't go anywhere that day they said President EO ki andaru okay anali anthe kani constitutional things EO tho lepestham ante every Trump and Biden will change things every 4 years with a pen. Then why do you need a congress or judicial system in USA. You can do presidential rule simple ga. Manam matladinatha easy kadhu bro things. TPS was different story H4 EAD was different story. TPS was congress Bill originally but Biden used his presedential power to extend certain countries under some Section 8 rule but same type Trump canceled it. 

Admin ki H4 EAD or OPT extension lepali ane thought vasthe yes they can make rule making original ki against ga. Lobbying matters here inside the white house 😊

US authorities roll out implementation plans on Trump's birthright citizenship order - Investing Abroad News | The Financial Express