CanadianMalodu Posted October 30 Report Posted October 30 56 minutes ago, rational said: Writing Allah and Quran verses on the floor is Haram? or not?. replica is a replica not being original annapudu daani meedha unna text okkate alteration ela avtundhi it could be part of original too? any proofs of casting the text later?. Also writing "allaho akbar" on non muslim objects like trishool or kalash is also haram? avuna kadha?. why would Muslims king do that? Letting a haram object trishool or kalash sit on top of monument once it was converted and for more than 150 years of Muslims ruled Agra and dozens of kings changed? why would any ruler allow to cast "allaho akbar" on already a haram object like trishool? First things first. If Original is altered, then replica made will look like altered original. Metallurgy predates iron age. It's not difficult add to engravings. Second point, show me other islamic structures with Trident/trishulam, Kalasam symbols and tell me the significance of those symbols in Islam. Quote
rational Posted November 1 Author Report Posted November 1 On 10/30/2025 at 10:38 PM, CanadianMalodu said: First things first. If Original is altered, then replica made will look like altered original. Metallurgy predates iron age. It's not difficult add to engravings. Second point, show me other islamic structures with Trident/trishulam, Kalasam symbols and tell me the significance of those symbols in Islam. how did you come to the conclusion that these engravings are added? just your own assumption? Archaeological evidence is better than personal opinions. Yes “purna kalasha” can be seen in various designs in Islamic structures they are just used as architectural representation. just google "how hindu, buddhist and jainism icon poorna kalasa adapted into sultanate and mughal architecture" you will find so many images and various versions of them too in mosques, tombs, monuments ". There are research papers explaining the adaptation. 1) Rani Sipri Mosque in Ahmedabad, Gujarat This is the mosque in Gujarat which is constructed by Hindu princess and his husband was a Muslim sultan, and there is an inscription of her commissioning construction of mosque after her son’s death. you will see the fusion mix of Hindu, jain and Muslim architecture. If you observe closely, you will see 2 kalash motifs top and bottom with lotus, incorporated in to the pillars and the middle leaf decoration is called kalpavalli also which is a significant symbol in Hinduism, Jainism, Buddhism. another pillar 2) Bhai harir sultani mosque with a big kalash on the front entrance with lotus flower and you will also see the similar pattern on the front pillars too. inscription of the construction of complex with has mosque and well by bahrir sultanate. 3) So called Trisool: This the small masjid built by the same Shajahan inside Agra fort called “nagina masjid” dedicated to the women in the royal family. The finial looks like the so called trishol, and there are archaeological records and inscriptions on the masjid which predates the construction of Taj mahal. And “Nagina” meaning precious stone, jewel etc in urdu nothing related to Hindu Diety Nagin. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.