Does Telangana benefit a lot from Hyd ?

[Telugodura456]

When state got separated everyone thought Telangana will be much much richer than andhra. But if you look at state budget and  gatra andhra always had higher revenue. how is it possible?

Simple the way taxes are designed in india, states get to keep only consumption tax whereas any exponential  growth like income tax and corporate tax Delhi keeps it.

So if amazon opens a center in hyd with 1000 employees running an average payroll of 30 laks per employee.  Then at 30% Delhi gets income tax alone of 90 crores every year. ON top of it corporate tax. what does state get ? if any of those 1000 employees come from out of state then their car registration tax, petrol tax for extra little petrol - just a few laks. Basically telangana gets all the pollution, high real estate price, other state people flooding the state with hindi etc  and just peanuts in money.

 

[Telugodura456]

That irritating fellow @Pappu_Packitmaar should know some facts.

[Telugodura456]

When you divide the state but without any actual transfer of power to states. what happens is more centralization not decentralization.

[DesiPokiri]

2 minutes ago, Telugodura456 said:

When you divide the state but without any actual transfer of power to states. what happens is more centralization not decentralization.

aa real estate chesi prices perigina lands anni maa ktr dealings chesthe maa kachara family rich e ga..

no matter what, we want rich dora n we fight like a gorre for him 

[Telugodura456]

2 minutes ago, DesiPokiri said:

aa real estate chesi prices perigina lands anni maa ktr dealings chesthe maa kachara family rich e ga..

no matter what, we want rich dora n we fight like a gorre for him 

Yes the elites will have oppurtunities to mint money. But the thing is Telangana does not have much elite also other than kachara etc. Andhra used to have elite - from industrialists to media to contractors.

ONe of the reason state govt divided is under CBN rule economy improved but all elite are from his pulkas which people did not like.

But the biggest pulka in india is delhi. Adhi gurthinchaka manalo manam kottuku chastham.

[gallikukka]

simple ga chebtha 

i am 3rd gen hyd born guy, here's my take, i never have voted and probably wont for some time , affiliation kooda  ledhu

maku vaddu, we want to be our own state  anukunnam, etlanooo oka laaga vachindhi

bagupaddamaa, bhrastu pattukupoyaamaa???  idhantha intellectual debate

is there a new TG state now ? yes

is there political uncertainity over hyd like between 2004-2014, daily dharnas etc? no 

is HYD , still marching ahead ? yes

are andhra's now outcast in HYD? no

are naxal's back in TG ? no

are communal riots back like in 90's ? no

is TG having food shortages? no

is TG having electricity shortages? no

is TG and HYD having water shortages? no

if the point was about diminished bargaining power at center for funds? Yes 42 to 17 and 25 does make a diff

but if center is indifferent either way then that point is moot, coz nothing much happened to AP state and HYD when YSR gave 33 seats to central govt in 2008 -09 elections. 

South gets shafted in broader indian perspective of central govt money dipsersion

some say South can afford that and BiMaRu states need hand holding a little longer 

just hope and pray that next Mp seat re-allocation and adjustment  doesnt happen on basis of population .... 

then South will get anally probed without any notice or gel.

[jalsa01]

27 minutes ago, Telugodura456 said:

When state got separated everyone thought Telangana will be much much richer than andhra. But if you look at state budget and  gatra andhra always had higher revenue. how is it possible?

Simple the way taxes are designed in india, states get to keep only consumption tax whereas any exponential  growth like income tax and corporate tax Delhi keeps it.

So if amazon opens a center in hyd with 1000 employees running an average payroll of 30 laks per employee.  Then at 30% Delhi gets income tax alone of 90 crores every year. ON top of it corporate tax. what does state get ? if any of those 1000 employees come from out of state then their car registration tax, petrol tax for extra little petrol - just a few laks. Basically telangana gets all the pollution, high real estate price, other state people flooding the state with hindi etc  and just peanuts in money.

 

State revenue wrt hyd revenue teesi chudu.. u get a better picture..

[Telugodura456]

1 minute ago, gallikukka said:

simple ga chebtha 

i am 3rd gen hyd born guy, here's my take, i never have voted and probably wont for some time , affiliation kooda  ledhu

maku vaddu, we want to be our own state  anukunnam, etlanooo oka laaga vachindhi

bagupaddamaa, bhrastu pattukupoyaamaa???  idhantha intellectual debate

is there a new TG state now ? yes

is there political uncertainity over hyd like between 2004-2014, daily dharnas etc? no 

is HYD , still marching ahead ? yes

are andhra's now outcast in HYD? no

are naxal's back in TG ? no

are communal riots back like in 90's ? no

is TG having food shortages? no

is TG having electricity shortages? no

is TG and HYD having water shortages? no

if the point was about diminished bargaining power at center for funds? Yes 42 to 17 and 25 does make a diff

but if center is indifferent either way then that point is moot, coz nothing much happened to AP state and HYD when YSR gave 33 seats to central govt in 2008 -09 elections. 

South gets shafted in broader indian perspective of central govt money dipsersion

some say South can afford that and BiMaRu states need hand holding a little longer 

just hope and pray that next Mp seat re-allocation and adjustment  doesnt happen on basis of population .... 

then South will get anally probed without any notice or gel.

I dont think any swargam came to telangana - nor telangana has any "richness" that it thought was missing. . Power cuts are gone (most of india) as past power plants came online and industrial demand went down as indian industry hollowed out preferring imports from china,

THe primary purpose of india is to transfer money to hindi belt from rest of states and push hindi out to rest of india. They even started one nation-one ration card - so south states with better PDS can fund the hindi migrants.

[Pappu_Packitmaar]

1 minute ago, jalsa01 said:

State revenue wrt hyd revenue teesi chudu.. u get a better picture..

But enduku teeyali ? 

[Pappu_Packitmaar]

Benefit ayinda..leda..ani evadu adigindu ?

[Telugodura456]

2 minutes ago, jalsa01 said:

State revenue wrt hyd revenue teesi chudu.. u get a better picture..

state revenue is just population revenue baa - nothing more - just consumption revenue. Anduke divide aina kooda andhra ki revenue ekkuva undhi. You eat food state gets gst share. but just because you are rich you dont eat twice food right ?or travel 5 times more. There will be some increase thats all.

Hyd revenue is because it has 20% of telangan populaton thats all.

[Pappu_Packitmaar]

29 minutes ago, Telugodura456 said:

That irritating fellow @Pappu_Packitmaar should know some facts.

When did I claim such stuff and why do I need to know the facts ? 
 

Evadanna eediki oka peg President medal poyadira ra ayya...sachipoyetattu vunnadu.

[Telugodura456]

Just now, Pappu_Packitmaar said:

When did I claim such stuff and why do I need to know the facts ? 
 

Evadanna eediki oka peg President medal poyadira ra ayya...sachipoyetattu vunnadu.

maa hyd maa hyd ani egirinaavuga. Analyze chesi cheppina neeku musli floods thappa yem ledhani.

[Pappu_Packitmaar]

Just now, Telugodura456 said:

maa hyd maa hyd ani egirinaavuga. Analyze chesi cheppina neeku musli floods thappa yem ledhani.

Maa Hyd ae...

Maa Hyd ae chepukonika facts telsukovala ? Hyd revenue telsukovala ?

Nenu emana Andhronna ivanni telsukonika ? Aina nakem avasaram ? 
 

Maa Hyd..Hamara Hyd..!! A mazaak odu iche 30 lakhs salary and what’s that non sha1t that you spoke, alantivi anni Amaravati la Telugu language Lo chepuko...

Hyd maadi ani chepukonika emotional connect vundali, Amazon iche 30 lakhs salary, andulo central govt share anta...

[snoww]

36 minutes ago, Telugodura456 said:

When state got separated everyone thought Telangana will be much much richer than andhra. But if you look at state budget and  gatra andhra always had higher revenue. how is it possible?

Simple the way taxes are designed in india, states get to keep only consumption tax whereas any exponential  growth like income tax and corporate tax Delhi keeps it.

So if amazon opens a center in hyd with 1000 employees running an average payroll of 30 laks per employee.  Then at 30% Delhi gets income tax alone of 90 crores every year. ON top of it corporate tax. what does state get ? if any of those 1000 employees come from out of state then their car registration tax, petrol tax for extra little petrol - just a few laks. Basically telangana gets all the pollution, high real estate price, other state people flooding the state with hindi etc  and just peanuts in money.

 

Do you have per capita stats ?