dasari4kntr Posted February 27, 2024 Report Posted February 27, 2024 Just now, Android_Halwa said: TAX rate uniform ga vundi ante, idi naak telsu anta... TAX rate uniform enduku vundi ani adigithe, tax rate uniform ga vundi ani nak telsu ani samadhanam... vankara tinkara ani dinne antaru... Malli okasari septunna vinu...why is tax rate levied uniform across all the regions, irrespective of their economic outputs. deeniki example ga Andhra, Bihar in India, California, Mississippi in USA ga case study ga teesuko...or perhaps any other country as you like. 'WHY'...ante 'enduku'...niku telusa telvada ani adugutalenu, why does rich states and poor states contribute the same tax rates ? Samajh mein aara ? Question ardam aitunda ? naaku telusu neeku telusu ane bochhulo gola pakkana petti... why central is not distributing the same back to state ane daaniki nee comment enti... vanka tinkara lekunda straight gaa cheppu... ettagu nuvvu deniki straight gaa cheppav kaani..edo naa chinna aasa... Quote
pichhipullayya Posted February 27, 2024 Report Posted February 27, 2024 @dasari4kntr @Android_Halwa Anna Lu Idi naa parstiti 1 Quote
dasari4kntr Posted February 27, 2024 Report Posted February 27, 2024 Just now, Android_Halwa said: Naku telsindi niku teliyali ante niku entha telso nak ardam kavali kada... anduke oka two questions adigithe, madhyalo finance commission patkochinav... Lal Salaam kadu, Lol salaam ayitundi... point lenappudu ilanti sollu maatalu cheppali.... nenu modati nundi finance commision gurinche maatladutunna...ee thread lo ayina...madyalo nuvve tax ante enti ani vankatra tinkara argument techinaav.... Quote
dasari4kntr Posted February 27, 2024 Report Posted February 27, 2024 Just now, pichhipullayya said: @dasari4kntr @Android_Halwa Anna Lu Idi naa parstiti confirm gaa maa argument neeku artham kaadu endkukante...inkaa halwa emi straight gaa cheppaledhu kaabatii... 1 Quote
Android_Halwa Posted February 27, 2024 Report Posted February 27, 2024 8 minutes ago, dasari4kntr said: naaku telusu neeku telusu ane bochhulo gola pakkana petti... why central is not distributing the same back to state ane daaniki nee comment enti... vanka tinkara lekunda straight gaa cheppu... ettagu nuvvu deniki straight gaa cheppav kaani..edo naa chinna aasa... Because the center is not obligated to distribute the taxes UNIFORMLY. The collection of taxes ensures and guarantees certain rights. If a state is paying more in taxes, that means they have used more resources available than other states and hence they pay more taxes. Tamil Nadu la Kudankulam Nuclear Plant, which is built using central funds, 90% of electricity goes to Tamil Nadu and it is a rich state contributing more. Maharastra uses more resources to churn out more economic output, The center assures seamless access to such resources and in return expects more taxes. Chhatisgarh produces more percapita power and exports and for that, they use infrastructure funded by other states. In the absence of TAX, every state will empower its own resources and tend to charge more or levy royalty, make resources inaccessible t other states and exert complete sovereignty over its resources. The union government ensures that resources are seamless for anyone who needs, for some one who has a power plant in kerela needs coal, we do not have oil resources yet we have gas stations selling gas, itla quote chesthu pothe 10000's of examples vuntayi why TAX is levied...and not distributed uniformly. This is how tax structure works and this is how it works in every part of the world. nenu ekuva tax kadtunna, nenu takua tax kaduthunna ane argument 'choti soch' and means nothing. Nee lantollu last 75 years ga ie ;anyayam' gurinchi matladutune vunnaru...just that 'matladutune vuntaru' Quote
Android_Halwa Posted February 27, 2024 Report Posted February 27, 2024 15 minutes ago, dasari4kntr said: point lenappudu ilanti sollu maatalu cheppali.... nenu modati nundi finance commision gurinche maatladutunna...ee thread lo ayina...madyalo nuvve tax ante enti ani vankatra tinkara argument techinaav.... Finance Commission endi vayya...nuvu nee lolli. Finance Comission only recommends to MoF ae Thapa they don't ensure fund allocation and distribution...its the secretary and minister in charge who finalizes the distribution on the need and outcome of the government. I think you are in a very wrong assumption...Finance Commissions, Five years plans previously, NITI Aayigs Vallaki only recommend ae Thapa inka ae power vundadu...every government has its priorities and accordingly distribution prepare chestaru, there a committee of MP's, Finance Commitee ani, they take representations from MP's and forward this recommendatiosn to the ministry, This is more considerate than finance commission. Quote
AnandaVivek Posted February 27, 2024 Report Posted February 27, 2024 Adenti peru modigpt ani kada undali!!! Approve ela ayyindi assalu 1 Quote
dasari4kntr Posted February 27, 2024 Report Posted February 27, 2024 23 minutes ago, Android_Halwa said: Because the center is not obligated to distribute the taxes UNIFORMLY. The collection of taxes ensures and guarantees certain rights. If a state is paying more in taxes, that means they have used more resources available than other states and hence they pay more taxes. Tamil Nadu la Kudankulam Nuclear Plant, which is built using central funds, 90% of electricity goes to Tamil Nadu and it is a rich state contributing more. Maharastra uses more resources to churn out more economic output, The center assures seamless access to such resources and in return expects more taxes. Chhatisgarh produces more percapita power and exports and for that, they use infrastructure funded by other states. In the absence of TAX, every state will empower its own resources and tend to charge more or levy royalty, make resources inaccessible t other states and exert complete sovereignty over its resources. The union government ensures that resources are seamless for anyone who needs, for some one who has a power plant in kerela needs coal, we do not have oil resources yet we have gas stations selling gas, itla quote chesthu pothe 10000's of examples vuntayi why TAX is levied...and not distributed uniformly. This is how tax structure works and this is how it works in every part of the world. nenu ekuva tax kadtunna, nenu takua tax kaduthunna ane argument 'choti soch' and means nothing. Nee lantollu last 75 years ga ie ;anyayam' gurinchi matladutune vunnaru...just that 'matladutune vuntaru' సరే rich south states ఆ బీద రాష్ట్రాలకి బిచ్చం వేసాయి అనుకుందాం…కానీ న్యాయభద్దంగా రావాలస్సిన డబ్బుల్ని కూడా కక్కుర్తి పడి ఇవ్వకుండా ఎగదెంగే వాల్లని ఏమంటాం…? అలాంటి వాళ్ళని వెనకేసుకచ్చి ఇలా తింగరి ఆర్గుమెంటు చేసే వాళ్ళని ఏమంటాం..? ఇచ్చేదే పావలా…దాంట్లో మళ్ళీ బకాయిలు….అడక్క తినే వాడి దెగ్గర గీక్క తినేవాడిలా ఉంది… JUST FYI..this is math they showed in assembly...if you understand or any intention to understand go through the numbers…. Quote
dasari4kntr Posted February 27, 2024 Report Posted February 27, 2024 11 minutes ago, Android_Halwa said: Finance Commission endi vayya...nuvu nee lolli. Finance Comission only recommends to MoF ae Thapa they don't ensure fund allocation and distribution...its the secretary and minister in charge who finalizes the distribution on the need and outcome of the government. I think you are in a very wrong assumption...Finance Commissions, Five years plans previously, NITI Aayigs Vallaki only recommend ae Thapa inka ae power vundadu...every government has its priorities and accordingly distribution prepare chestaru, there a committee of MP's, Finance Commitee ani, they take representations from MP's and forward this recommendatiosn to the ministry, This is more considerate than finance commission. aa mukka maaku telusu halwa...nee notitho nuvve oppukunnav...central is cheating south states ani... 2017 lo CBN govt baane tirigindhi negotiations kosam...tippukunnare kaane...malli visham gakkaru...ippudu next financial commission kooda same vuntundi... Quote
pizzaaddict Posted February 27, 2024 Report Posted February 27, 2024 Desam kosam ekkadikaina velley leader ani followers feeling. Quote
Raisins_72 Posted February 27, 2024 Report Posted February 27, 2024 28 minutes ago, pizzaaddict said: BharatChat ki ee Modi pics ki sambandham endhi ba 😂😂 #ippudu kaakapothey inkeppudu aney type lo pothunnaav roju roju ki 😉 Quote
pizzaaddict Posted February 27, 2024 Report Posted February 27, 2024 57 minutes ago, Raisins_72 said: BharatChat ki ee Modi pics ki sambandham endhi ba 😂😂 #ippudu kaakapothey inkeppudu aney type lo pothunnaav roju roju ki 😉 Leader bhajana next level lo undhi ga , In general post chesa baa. Quote
pizzaaddict Posted February 27, 2024 Report Posted February 27, 2024 59 minutes ago, Raisins_72 said: BharatChat ki ee Modi pics ki sambandham endhi ba 😂😂 #ippudu kaakapothey inkeppudu aney type lo pothunnaav roju roju ki 😉 Scuba diving matram comedy , roju roju ki drama next level loki veltundhi. Quote
Android_Halwa Posted February 28, 2024 Report Posted February 28, 2024 3 hours ago, dasari4kntr said: aa mukka maaku telusu halwa...nee notitho nuvve oppukunnav...central is cheating south states ani... 2017 lo CBN govt baane tirigindhi negotiations kosam...tippukunnare kaane...malli visham gakkaru...ippudu next financial commission kooda same vuntundi... Lol Comrade, vasthavam cheppina Thapa ida emundi ani oppukodaniki ? 2018 la Union Govt asked for utilization certificates for various schemes including capital for which it earmarked 1500 crs, but visionaru babu garu okka UC kuda submit cheyaledu...idi swayana mantri garu parliament la chepinaru for a question raised by kanakamedala ravinddra kumar. Anyway, have you seen any state going to the supreme court for central government not getting its rightful share in taxes? As per constitution, every state gets its rightful share and there is no skipping on this part. Other than these tax shares, state governments ask for grants, one-time help, interest-free loans, part share in project execution, and many such financial instruments which get delayed. Do you really think world class capital kadutha ante central government fund chestadi antava ? Remember, indaka chepinatu MP's tho finance comiitee vutadi ani, capital plan a committee clear chestada ? in such instances, edo one time help or inkedo scheme tho help chestaru and ear marks a budget for such a spend over a time on subject to condition the state government provides utilization certificates else no further fund will be released. In case of AP, Polavaram nundi Capital varaku okka UC kuda submit cheyaledu ippativaraku and this is the reason why no funds are allocated, existing vaatitho pani chesukondi lekapothey dobbey annaru. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.